Home Message Board Pick 'em Page Picks & Results Pt Standings Wkly Composites Official Rules Awards Record Archives Handicapper Capsules
Bookie Challenge
WEEKLY REVIEW

October 15, 2025 | Issue #7 | Week #6

Parts Unknown (DP--Disassociated Press): If anything, this year's 15th Annual Bookie Challenge competition is off to its most chaotic start ever. After the first-six weeks of this year's competition only one thing is certain so far, and it is that this season has been inundated with a litany of bizarre handicapping shortcomings by many of the Challenge field's handicappers. It's as if the posting guidelines have been tossed out of a window and many a handicapper from the competition have failed to adhere to the official rules of the Bookie Challenge, whether written rules or unwritten rules. As an example of the handicapping pandemonium that has stricken this year's competition, just read the following: For starters, there have been a slew of disqualified weekly selections, the likes of which have never been seen before. Participants such as one-year veteran Kr@tos and rookies Kennypie86 and Matty_Ice have already lost invaluable scoring opportunities because of disqualified picks or for having missed posting weekly picks. Secondly, too many seasoned veterans have also committed the league's Cardinal Sin and have missed posting weekly selections, such as Theopholis, dbucc, and DawgPound. They too have missed out on invaluable scoring opportunities. But overall, the worst offender so far in this year's competition has been rookie Kennypie86. However, we'll get to the shaky rookie soon enough, but first let's take the temperature of this year's competition.

After this past weekend, after the Biased Nihilist was the only handicapper to connect on both of his respective best bets, he gained a crucial point over second-place Vikings17 and now leads the competition by six points over this year's defending champion (Nihilist 22pts vs Vikings17 16pts). With the Nihilist presently holding down the top seed in the standings and Vikings17 occupying the second seed, the last two important seeds, meaning the third and the fourth seeds, are being possessed by Driveline (3rd seed/10 pts) and Kr@tos (4th seed/10pts). In the case of Kr@tos, who opened up this season with a rare 3-point parlay hit, he was able to rebound from his posting gaffe from week #5 in which his parlay combination got disqualified, and this past weekend he nailed his first-ever exact-score pick, of which he was the only participant in the league who entered this past weekend without registering an exact-score point in his Challenge career. It was a big point too and one that couldn't have come at a better time. So after Kr@tos won one of his best bets and collected his first exact-score point, his two points for the week was good enough to jump over dbucc and Blitzkrieg in the point standings to secure--for the time being--the fourth top seed. Kr@tos actually tied Driveline with 10 total points on the season, but Driveline won the tiebreaker over Kr@tos for the official third-seed slot because of one more best bet winner (7 vs 6). But Kr@tos, nor Driveline for that matter, can rest on his laurels because immediately below them in the standings are Blitzkrieg (9pts) and dbucc (also 9pts). What's more, the rest of the handicappers below Blitzkrieg and dbucc are tightly knit in the standings and all are within a PERFECTA's outing from acquiring either the third or fourth top seed.

However, the reality of the situation is not a good one for the handicappers who trail the Nihilist (22pts) and second-place Vikings17 (16pts) in the standings, especially when considering that this year's all-important divisional seeding is just two more outings from taking place. In other words, for all the handicappers who trail the Nihilist and Vikings17 in the standings, it would take some serious handicapping miracles for any of them to pull out the number-one or number-two top seeds at this year's divisional seeding. To be more specific, all the handicappers not named the Biased Nihilist or Vikings17 would need to hit back-to-back 6-point parlay hits in the next two weeks in order to snag one of the top two seeds at this year's divisional seeding. Speaking of which, hitting 6-point parlay winners in this year's competition are at a premium, seeing as the Biased Nihilist has hit the ONLY two 6-point parlay winners after the first-six weeks of this year's contest. Keeping the aforementioned in mind, the Biased Nihilist is presently the prohibitive favorite to capture his first-ever number-one top seed when given that he owns all of the top tiebreakers, that is, should he even need them.

During the next two weeks, or the last two weeks before this year's divisional seeding rolls around, a couple of handicappers have serious shots at displacing either Driveline or Kr@tos in the point standings for the third seed and fourth seed, respectively, and they are Blitzkrieg and dbucc. Remember that Blitzkrieg is the handicapper who is always "in the thick of things" and that he is one of the league's better handicappers when it comes to landing 6-point parlay winners. Also keep in mind that Blitzkrieg presently owns the top best-bet record in the league, of which his best-bet tally sits at 8-4-0 on the season and factors out to a league-high .667 winning percentage. Meanwhile, despite that dbucc didn't post any weekly selections last weekend, he's still right there in the immediate periphery from getting one of the top seeds in the standings.

And now it's time to dissect this year's most recalcitrant handicapper of this season's competition. of whom is the rookie who hails by the username of Kennypie86. To begin with, the competition's main administrator, the Biased Nihilist, can't recall a rookie who has screwed up more times to start off his rookie debut than has the "Ken Doll" (aka Kennypie86). He got smashed while tailgating at the Buccaneers' season opener in Atlanta this season and then failed to post his weekly set of selections, including his preseason Super Bowl picks. In hindsight, after the first FIVE weeks of this year's competition, after having missed posting his initial set of picks back in week #1, it turned out that it didn't matter that Kennypie missed posting his season-opening picks because his handicapping has sucked so bad. Case in point, if not for connecting on his first career exact-score point back in week #4, he would have goose egged that particular weekend, which meant that he would have goose egged four of his first five weeks of the season. Additionally, in week #4 he didn't beat the posting deadline for the game played in Ireland, and a consequence he had his parlay combination disqualified. One would think he would have learned his lesson, would have found out what missing a posting deadline entailed, but no! As insane as it sounds, the Ken Doll made the same posting mistake in week #5 and so had his parlay combination disqualified for a second week in a row. The Nihilist put it best, "I've never seen a more incorrigible participant in all my years of running the Bookie Challenge."

Then came last weekend, and with it came some more controversy overshadowing Kennypie86's outing. To start off, in what has to be deemed as the shocker of the year, the Ken Doll tallied three points for the weekend and WON THE WEEK OUTRIGHT! The Nihilist achieved the same feat back in week #2, meaning he won week #2 outright after scoring just three total points. But when it came to Kennypie's three-point outing, he miraculously connected on both ends of this past weekend's exact-score games and thus he picked up two lucky points. However, the third point that the Ken Doll won this past weekend came about only because he copied and pasted the entire weekly selections that Driveline posted, and the evidence is irrefutable. Eventually, Driveline only scored one pointthis past weekend after he won one of his best bets, and so by extension, after copying Driveline's picks to the letter, Kennypie also won a best bet. The point was a major difference maker for Kennypie despite him not "making" the selection. Now granted, it's not against the rules to purposely copy someone else's picks, with the exception being that no picks can be copied in the last week of the regular season, but what the Ken Doll pulled off this past weekend was against the spirit of the competition, not to mention that it was a rogue manuever that also went against the spirit of fair play. To say the least, in the headlines of this weekly review is a picture of kennypie donning a Buccaneers' outfit. But what is most fitting about the picture is that he painted two black circles around his eyes, and after executing the unconscionable this past weekend--one can say that he earned two black eyes because of his underhanded behavior. All things considered, it should be needless to say to stay tuned, because something says that we haven't seen the last of the ken Doll's shenanigans in this year's competition.


WEEKLY ODDS AND ENDS: THE HANDICAPPING HODGEPODGE

  • WEEK #6'S NEAR-MISSES OF 6-POINT PARLAY HITS: In a Bookie Challenge season that has been mainly bereft of 6-point parlay winners, this past weekend was more of the same, as in not a single 6-point parlay combination came to fruition for the Bookie Challenge field. This past weekend's handful of handicappers who felt the excruciating heartbreak of near-misses of their respective parlay combinations because of only one losing parlay pick were 7mick7, TCU, Theopholis, and rookie Matty_Ice. To break down the heartbreak, 7mick7's parlay combo was derailed after the LA Chargers (-4) lost to the spread versus Miami, while over.under parlay picks brought down the respective parlay combinations of TCU (lost over pick of Det/KC game--KC won 30-17), Theopholis (lost the under of the Dall/Car game--Car won 30-27). and Matty_Ice (lost the over of the Buff/Atl game--Atl won 24-14).


  • WEEKLY TICKER.................Two-year veteran Jets69 was spared a golden goose egg outing this past weekend after he connected on his third 1-point exact-score winner of the season...........Over/under selections by the Challenge field are still underwater so far for this season. After this past weekend's handicapping action ran its course, the Challenge field's combined over/under record for the season is a combined 24-34-0 (win% .413).................


CHALLENGE FIELD: WEEKLY COMBINED STATS AND HAPPENINGS
WEEKLY RESULTS (Thru Week #6)
Week/YTD Best Bet Record Win % Total Pts Exact-Scores

5pt-------2pt---------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt Parlays 6pt Parlays Perfectas Goose Eggs Golden Goose Eggs Wins Within Parlay Consensus Picks
Week #6 10-16-0 .385 14 0 0 x4 4 0 0 0 3 1 15 consensus 0-2-0
W% .000
YTD 76-91-2 .455 128 x2 x2 x18 32 1 2 0 14 2 102 consensus 3-5-0
W% .375
Single-Season
Records
504-414-33
(Yr#5)
.549 (Yr#5) 1087 (Yr#8) x4
(Yrs #8
& #6)
x2
Yr#14
X44
(Yr#14)
241
(Yr#9)
9
(Yr#7)
56 (Yr#8) 19
(Yr#8)
92 (Yr#8) 23 (Yr#4) 631 (Yr#8) 16-8-2
W%.667 (Yr#4)

  • WHAT THE HECK IS GOING ON WITH THIS YEAR'S CHALLENGE FIELD?!: Without a shadow of a doubt, this year's Challenge field is presently lost. This past weekend the field had another horrible outing, of which the hapless tally of just 14 total points came on the heels of their worst outing of 13 total points that was scored in the previous week (wk #5). Just to show how bad things have gotten, the only consistent statistic that this year's field has so far racked up every week of this season is the propensity to lay goose eggs and a couple of golden goose eggs. Otherwise, with the exception of the Biased Nihilist and a couple of other participants, this year's handicappers within the field couldn't pick pointspread winners even if they had Monday morning's sports page ahead of time. In fact, this year's field is off to the worst start ever that at year's end it might become the worst Challenge field to handicap a competition in the history of the Bookie Challenge. The present numbers just don't lie. This year's field has a combined best-bet record for the season of 76-91-2 for a lowly .455 win percentage. Moreover, and what is totally inexplicable, is that this year's field is struggling to no end to knock down 6-point parlay winners. If the not for the Nihilist, who has connected on the only two 6-point parlay hits this season, this year's field would not have registered a single 6-point parlay winner for the first six weeks of this year's handicapping campaign. As a matter of record, one would have to go as far back as Challenge year #3 to find the last time a Challenge field had a worst start with its parlay hits by a Challenge field than this year's field. Back then that year's Challenge field only registered four 6-point parlays winners through the first-six weeks of that season's competition. Right now, this year's field is misfiring so badly that even its consensus selections went 0-2-0 this past weekend and now has a year-long tally of 3-5-0 (win% .375) for this season. The only silver lining for the current state of this year's Challenge field is that things can't possibly get any worse than they are right now. Or could they?


WHO'S HOT AND WHO'S NOT
WHO'S HOT: Biased Nihilist

The Corozal Kid is right where he wants to be, which is to be the envy of the league. Two weeks are what separates the Biased Nihilist from seizing his first-ever number-one top seed. There are a lot of naysayers within the Challenge field who keep stammering some garbage about how "t-t-the Nihilist is f-f-fixing to fall." But because nobody has been able to hit any 6-point parlay winners, other than the self-proclaimed "Greatest Handicapper of All Time", the Nihilist might just back into this year's overall number-one top seed. In fact, let's be real, the Nihilist only has to ward off Vikings17 over the span of the next two weeks and he'll be the talk of the town, that is, if he already isn't. Oh, and as it concerns Vikings17, he needs to pass over the Nihilist within the next two weeks, because ending up tied in total points will not cut it for the Purple People Eater. What's clear as day is that the Nihilist holds all the top tiebreakers against Vikings17, such as more best-bet wins (7 vs 5), more parlay wins within his parlay combinations (11 vs 7), and more weeks won (3 vs 1). Yes, the Nihilist presently is the clear-cut favorite to win this year's overall number-one top seed, especially if he can add another two points or so to his lead over Vikings17 this upcoming weekend. And if the Corozal Kid does increase his lead, it would only leave Vikings17 one last chance in week #8 to pull off a handicapping miracle.

WHO'S NOT: Hall-of-Fame City Kid

Now that Kennypie86 has ignominiously vacated this segment of the weekly review, there are a good handful of struggling handicappers who could easily take his place as this week's WHO'S-NOT-HOT-HANDICAPPER. One of the viable candidates who could conceivably take over this segment of the weekly review is veteran participant jcvike28, who is presently in the throes of having his worst start to a Bookie Challenge competition. This past weekend, jcvike uncharacteristically followed up a previous goose egg outing back in week #5 with a shameful golden goose egg outing this past weekend. One has to remember that in last year's competition "El Duque" (aka jcvike) became only the second participant in the history of the Bookie Challenge to handicap an entire season without recording a scoreless outing (no goose eggs nor golden goose eggs), of which is an extremely difficult all-time record to duplicate. The only other handicapper to pull off the feat was dbucc, who accomplished the phenomenal all-time record back in Challenge year #5. But as it concerns jcvike's dispiriting start to this year's competition, it is that he has produced the worst best-bet tally in the league, having gone an overall 2-10-0 so far for this year's competition. When doing the math, his appalling best-bet mark factors out to a disgraceful .167 winning percentage, which is quite puzzling when considering that he was honored with last year's Swami award (honor given to the handicapper with the league' top best-bet record for a season). But believe it or not, despite jcvike having only accrued four total points on the season and having plopped down two goose eggs and one golden goose egg, he's not being singled out this week for being the WHO'S-NOT-HOT-HANDICAPPER. No, that dubious distinction belongs to the Hall-of-Fame City Kid, who is now at rock-bottom of the competition's point standings. As it stands after this past weekend, the City Kid has compiled a miserable point tally of just three overall points so far this season, which is the worst point total in the league. This past weekend, if one can believe it, the HOF City Kid laid his third consecutive goose egg and his fourth goose egg of the season. Oh, and despite the fact that the City Kid is off to another horrible start (see rookie season from two years ago), he does have one big-time fan who is showering his handicapping with nothing but praises. In fact, jcvike is clapping so hard that his hands are swollen beyond recognition.


POINT STANDINGS (Thru Week #6)
Total Pts Participant Best Bet Record Win % Weeks Won Exact Scores Propositional Pts 3pt Parlays 6pt Parlays Perfectas Goose Eggs Golden Goose-Eggs Wins in Parlays
22 pts B.Nihilist* 7-5-0 .583 3 0 0 1pt(x3) 3 0 2 0 0 0 11
16 pts Vikings17* 5-7-0 .417 1 5pt(x2) 0 1pt(x1) 11 0 0 0 0 0 7
10 pts Driveline* 7-5-0 .583 0 0 2pt(x1) 1pt(x1) 3 0 0 0 1 0 8
10 pts Kr@tos* 6-5-1 .545 0 0 0 1pt 1 1 0 0 0 1 5
9 pts Blitzkrieg* 8-4-0 .667 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 1 0 0 0 0 0 8
9 pts dbucc 5-5-0 .500 0 0 0 1pt(x4) 4 0 0 0 1 0 7
8 pts Matty_Ice* 6-4-0 .600 0 0 2pt(x1) 0 2 0 0 0 1 0 5
8 pts Theopholis 6-4-0 .600 0 0 0 1pt(x2) 2 0 0 0 0 0 5
7 pts Jets69* 5-7-0 .417 0 0 0 1pt(x2) 2 0 0 0 2 0 6
6 pts DawgPound 6-4-0 .600 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 8
6 pts TCU* 5-6-1 .455 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 7
5 pts 7mick7* 4-8-0 .333 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 1 0 0 0 1 0 8
5 pts Kennypie86* 2-7-0 .222 1 0 0 1pt(x3) 3 0 0 0 3 0 3
4 pts jcvike28 2-10-0 .167 0 0 0 1pt(x2) 2 0 0 0 2 1 5
3 pts HOFCityKid 3-9-0 .250 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 7
Statistics in BOLD denotes participant leads league in statistical category.
Asterisk next to participant's name denotes his membership fees have been received. Total projected jackpot: $750 (Current jackpot: $500). Projected split of jackpot: 1st place at end of playoffs $500, 2nd place at end of playoffs $100, 3rd place prize Regular season champion $100, and 4th place prize overall Top Seed from divisional seeding (Wk#8) $50.

INDIVIDUAL PICKS (NFL WEEK #6)
(Note: Participants are listed in order in which they posted their picks)
Participant Best Bets Parlay Exact Scores Propositional Picks Results >>>>> Total Pts W-L-T Week Won Exact-Scores

5pt------2pt------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt parlay 6pt parlay Perfecta Goose Egg Golden Goose-Egg Wins in Parlay
7mick7 Pitts-5½-W
Jax-1-L
LV-5-W
TB-3-W
LAC-4-L
Phi 24-17

Was 27-24
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
dbucc NoPick
NoPick
NoPick
NoPick
NoPick
Phi 27-16

xs
N/A >>>>> 0 pts GE NoPicks
Blitzkrieg KC-2½-W
Wash-4½-L
Dall-3-L
TB-3-W
Jax-1-L
Phi 27-20

Was 27-20
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
Jets69 Cle+5½-L
Ind-7-L
NO+3-L
Tenn+5-L
LAC-4-L
NYG 24-20

Was 24-20--w
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 0-2-0 1pt PP-1pt 0/3
Kennypie86 Pitts-5½-W
NO+3½-L
Ind-7-L
Mia+4-W
Dall-3-L
NYG 31-17--W

Was 24-17--W
N/A >>>>> 3 pts 1-1-0 WW 1pt(x2) PP-2pts 1/3
Driveline Pitts-5½-W
NO+3½-L
Ind-7-L
Mia+4-W
Dall-3-L
Phi 31-13

Was 27-17
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
TCU Dall-3-L
Wash-4½-L
Det/KC-O53-L
Cin+15-W
LAC/Mia-O44-W
Phi 30-27

Was 28-20
N/A >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GE 2/3
Kr@tos Buff-4½-L
Pitts-5½-W
LAC-4-L
NE-3-W
Jax-1-L
Phi 31-23

Was 24-17--W
N/A >>>>> 2 pts 1-1-0 1-pt PP-1pt 1/3
jcvike28 Cle+6-L
Dall-3-L
Ind-7-L
Jax-1-L
Wash-5-L
Phi 27-13

Was 27-20
N/A >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GGE 0/3
Vikings17 Phil-7½-L
Phi/NYG-040½-W
Ind-7-L
LAR-7-W
LAC-4-L
Phi 30-20

Was 34-31
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
B.Nihilist Cin/GB-O44½-W
KC-2½-W
LAC-4-L
TB-3-W
Buff-5-L
Phi 27-13

Was 27-23
N/A >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 1/3
Matty_Ice Det+2½-L
Sea+1-W
Ten/LV-U42-W
NE-3-W
Buf/Atl-O50-L
NoPick

Was 26-20
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
Theopholis Pitts-5½-W
Jax-1-L
Cin+15-W
Dal/Car-U50-L
Mia+4-W
NoPick

Was 26-22
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
HOF City Kid Ind-7-L
Buff-4½-L
Dall-3-L
SF+3-L
Sea+1-W
NoPick

Was 27-20
N/A >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GE 1/3
DawgPound No Picks Posted

FINALS NYG 34
PHIL 17
DEN 13
NYJ 11
PITTS 23
CLE 9
IND 31
ARI 27
LAR 17
BALT 3
SEA 20
JAX 12
CAR 30
DALL 27
LAC 29
MIA 27
NE 25
NO 19
LV 20
TENN 10
TB 30
SF 19
GB 27
CIN 18
KC 30
DET 17
BUFF
ATL 24
BUFF 14
CHI 25
WASH 24

PREVIOUS REVIEWS Annual Special Wk#1 Wk#2 Wk#3 Wk#4 Wk#5