Home Message Board Pick 'em Page Picks & Results Pt Standings Wkly Composites Official Rules Awards Record Archives Handicapper Capsules
Bookie Challenge
WEEKLY REVIEW

September 24, 2025 | Issue #4 | Week #3

Parts Unknown (DP--Disassociated Press): It should be needless to say that most of the handicappers within the ranks of the Bookie Challenge field have yet to fine tune their respective handicapping games this season, as the field as a whole presently owns a barely bearable 44-40-2 best-bet record, which checks out to a .522 winning percentage. And to think, the only reason this year's Challenge field sports a winning best-bet record is because this past weekend the field went an astounding 20-10-0 with its best-bet record, which factors out to a much better .667 winning percentage. But what has really ailed the participants of the competition this season has been their inability to connect on their respective 6-point parlay combinations. With the exception of the Biased Nihilist, who this past weekend finally connected on the competition's first 6-point parlay winner, nobody else in the competition has nailed down any 6-point parlay hits this season. Granted, though, last year's rookie of the year, Kr@tos, did manage to eke out a 3-point parlay hit in the opening week of this season, and he did squeeze out an unconventional 4-point outing, but ever since the first week of the season Kr@tos has only accrued three total points over the two ensuing weeks. No, if the truth be told, this past weekend was all about the Nihilist and his clutch 8-point outing, and all about three other handicappers--Blitzkrieg, Driveline, and DawgPound--all of whom almost rose to the occasion and almost knocked down 6-point parlay hits to keep pace with the Corozal Kid (aka the Nihilist). Additionally, this past weekend was the first time this season that the competition shifted gears and produced an exciting outing of handicapping for a good change of pace.

It's not a big secret that the Biased Nihilist enjoys the spotlight, and that he'd rather see his name up on the marquee lights than anybody else's name, and that he loves to control the competition by getting into the heads of his adversarial foes. This past weekend the Nihilist portrayed a strong-mindedness and a tenacious grit of handicapping to piece together what must be labeled as a backdoor PERFECTA. In other words, instead of winning both of his best bets and nailing down a 6-point parlay winner to produce a natural PERFECTA (8 pts), the Nihilist knocked down one best-bet winner, a 6-point parlay hit, and a 1-point exact-score winner to manufacture his backdoor PERFECTA to tally eight total points for the weekend. As a result of his outstanding outing this past weekend, the Corozal Kid was able to open the first true daylight in the point standings after he took a five-point lead over second place Vikings17 (13pts vs 8pts). As a bonus, the Nihilist was able to snatch his second-straight week-won, which is an invaluable tiebreaker should he ever need it. Really and truly, the Nihilist is presently sitting pretty as it concerns tiebreakers. As it stands right now, the Nihilist is tied with a couple of handicappers for most best-bet winners (4 each), which is the league's first tiebreaker. He also owns the league's second tiebreaker (most parlay wins within his combined parlay combinations on the season), and as mentioned earlier, the Nihilist is easily holding down the league's third tiebreaker--most weeks-won (2).

"I've got the schmoes from the Challenge field right where I want them," quipped the Nihilist. "Some of them might not feel what's happening, but I've already got my hooks in them. Oh yes, I know how to win in this league so they're in trouble." Putting his cockiness aside, getting credited with a week-won this past weekend was not a walk in the park for the three-time Bookie Challenge champion. The start to this past Sunday after the early set of games became finals set the bar for the rest of the league for the remainder of the weekend, as the Nihilist knocked down his 6-point parlay combo that consisted of the following: Washington -3 over Las Vegas, Minnesota -3 over Cincinnati, and Pittsburgh -2 over New England. With the exception of the Pittsburgh/New England affair in which the Steelers struggled mightily to win by a TD 21-14, the other two games on the Nihilist's combo were runaway winners. But heading into the second set of games on this past Sunday, both Driveline and DawgPound were working on hitting respective 6-point parlay winners, and all they needed was for the LA Chargers to cover a 3-point spread over the Denver Broncos. Actually, Driveline was in line to hit a PERFECTA outing as he also won both of his best bets in the early slate of games. But it wasn't meant to be, as the LA Chargers kicked a late field goal to force a push on the parlay line after they defeated the Broncos by a 23-20 final. However, the Nihilist was one of three handicappers who took the Chargers as one of their respective best bets, and they had the presence of mind to choose the Chargers on the straight line as -2½-point favorites. The losses of parlay hits by Driveline and DawgPound because one game push on their respective combinations wasn't the only threat to the Biased Nihilist's week won,as Blitzkrieg just needed two more victories, both parlay picks, to hit a PERFECTA outing and at least tie the Nihilist for being the top scorer for the weekend (each would have ended the week with 8 pts apiece, notwithstanding any hits on Monday night's exact-score predictions). Blitzkrieg's last two picks on his parlay combo were Kansas City -6 over NY Giants on Sunday night and Baltimore -5 over Detroit on Monday nigt. Subsequently, after the Chiefs covered over the Giants by a 22-9 score, Blitzkrieg headed into Monday night's game needing just Baltimore to cover against Detroit to hit his PERFECTA weekend.

If anybody has already forgotten, Blitzkrieg won last year's overall number-one top seed at last year's divisional seeding. But he had an intensity-filled divisional race in which he was defeated by Vikings17 for the Hail Mary divisional title. One of the league's participants, specifically the Nihilist, chalked up Blitzkrieg's divisional defeat last season as being caused by the "Curse of the Number-One Top Seed, as no number-one top seed has ever gone on to win a Bookie Challenge championship. But if anything, last year's heartbreak loss by Blitzkrieg to Vikings17 further cemented his Bookie Challenge legacy as being a handicapper who is always in the thick of things. It's a Bookie Challenge reputation that Blitzkrieg has earned ever since he has started handicapping the Bookie Challenge competition. What's more, what's proof-positive when it comes to Blitzkrieg stacking up 6-point parlay winners is that he's the only active handicapper in the Bookie Challenge competition who's been in the league for nine years, excluding this season, and has recorded at least one 6-point parlay hit in each of his previous nine seasons. Sure, he fell short this past Monday night, but nobody should go to sleep when it comes to Blitzkrieg, for he can nail 6-point parlay winners with the best handicappers in the league, including the Biased Nihilist. Speaking of which, the 6-point parlay hit the Nihilist produced this past weekend was his first of this season, but it was his 42nd league-leading all-time 6-point parlay winner of his career (regular season and postseason combined).


WEEKLY ODDS AND ENDS: THE HANDICAPPING HODGEPODGE

  • ROOKIE MATTY_ICE SO FAR HAS EDGE OVER KEENYPIE86 FOR THIS YEAR'S ROOKIE-OF-THE-YEAR HONOR, BUT BOTH GREEHORNS HAVE YET TO "MAKE THEIR BONES" IN THE BOOKIE CHALLENGE COMPETITION: It might sound a little bit gangsterish, but this year's two rookies--Matty_Ice and Kennypie86--have yet to make their bones in the storied Bookie Challenge competition, meaning neither handicapper has hit a 6-point parlay yet. Traditionally speaking, until a rookie handicapper finally knocks down a 6-point parlay hit, he's nothing to the rest of the league. Yep, in the Bookie Challenge competition, you're nothing until you're everything, until your heart and soul is all in. But still, one of the two rookies, regardless if they don't make their bones, is going to win this year's Rookie-of-the-Year award. With that being said, for the time being, it's Matty_Ice who holds the early edge over Kennypie86 for this year's Rookie-of-the-Year nod. But Matty_Ice's present lead over Kennypie is based on him having more points scored (4pts vs 1pt) and a better best-bet record (4-2-0 vs 1-3-0), otherwise it's too early to tell who's going to best handle the early jitters of a rookie debut. So yes, it's early but Kennypie86 can't let things get away from him because his rookie season can easily go south if he doesn't focus on the little things, such as adhering strictly to the competition's rules and procedures. For example, Kennypie has already screwed up by missing his initial set of weekly selections back in week #1. Conversely, Matty_Ice has complied fully with what is required of him, as in he has made all of his weekly selections, to include posting every exact-score selection. Ordinarily, at some point of a rookie battle the high drama and suspense takes over and the competition is treated to another rookie fisticuffs, so to speak. One thing is already certain, Matty_Ice has already landed an overhand right to Kennypie's jaw. Now we have to see if Kennypie can get his footing underneath him and punch back.


  • WEEKLY TICKER.................. Both the Biased Nihilist and dbucc, two of league's seasoned veterans, have each connected on one-point exact-score hits for each of the first-three weeks of this year's competition...........Theopholis' return to the Bookie Challenge competition after missing last year's competition due to health concerns has been rocky and shaky at best, but nothing out of the ordinary. In other words, the league is already accustomed to seeing Theo screw things up in what seems like on a yearly basis. After having missed the posting deadline for the opening week of this season, this past weekend Theo tried his hardest to incorporate a 2-team parlay into the Bookie Challenge competition. But the competition's two administrators, the Nihilist and 7mick7, were not buying it. To make a long story short, Theo posted just two parlay picks as his 3-team parlay combination for the weekend, and as a consequence, he had his entire 3-team parlay combo disqualified. They say two out of three ain't bad, but in the Bookie Challenge it is.................This past weekend rookie Matty_Ice lost every parlay selection within his entire parlay combination, and done as much for the second time this season. In the process, he tied TCU for missing two full sets of 3-team parlay combinations so far this season................Ever since the league expanded its scoring format for exact-score selections in Challenge year #13, when it added one-point exact-score hits to the two-point and five-point exact-score selections it already had, the competition's propositional points skyrocketed. In fact, after the first three weeks of this year's competition, this year's Challenge field set a new all-time mark to open up a Bookie Challenge competition with the most prop points scored (20pts vs previous 3-week high of 14 prop pts in Challenge yr#14)...........


CHALLENGE FIELD: WEEKLY COMBINED STATS AND HAPPENINGS
WEEKLY RESULTS (Thru Week #3)
Week/YTD Best Bet Record Win % Total Pts Exact-Scores

5pt-------2pt---------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt Parlays 6pt Parlays Perfectas Goose Eggs Golden Goose Eggs Wins Within Parlay Consensus Picks
Week #3 20-10-0-0 .667 32 x1 x1 x5 5 0 1 0 5 0 18 consensus 1-1-0
W% .500
YTD 44-40-2 .523 74 x1 x1 x13 20 1 1 0 6 0 49 consensus 2-2-0
W% .500
Single-Season
Records
504-414-33
(Yr#5)
.549 (Yr#5) 1087 (Yr#8) x4
(Yrs #8
& #6)
x2
Yr#14
X44
(Yr#14)
241
(Yr#9)
9
(Yr#7)
56 (Yr#8) 19
(Yr#8)
92 (Yr#8) 23 (Yr#4) 631 (Yr#8) 16-8-2
W%.667 (Yr#4)

  • CHALLENGE FIELD'S OVER/UNDER RECORD IS SIX-FEET UNDER TO START 15TH ANNUAL COMPETITION!: What in the Sam hill is going on with the Challenge field's over/under selections in this year's competition? Holy camoly, Whatever is behind the extremely weak numbers concerning the field's over/under picks so far this season, it ain't pretty. And although official over/under tallies are not archived into the Challenge's record books, this year's over/under selections have been the worst ever to start off the first=three weeks of a Bookie Challenge competition. That previous statement is absolutely, 100 percent, correct despite not having the raw data of previous over/under starts to a competition. Case in point, there's no way that any previous Bookie Challenge fields have done worst than this year's field, nothing remotely close to having establishing this year's atrocious over/under record of 9-25-0, of which the inexplicable record factors out to a measly .264 win percentage of over/under picks. For the longest, over the span of the last eight years, TCU has been the main participant who regularly posted more over/under selections than any other participant in the league. Or at least that used to be the case until Vikings17 joined the league two years ago. Today both handicappers, to mean TCU and Vikings17 easily lead the league in posting over/under selections. Oddly, however, over/under selections have seemingly gone up exponentially, and already after the first three weeks of this season eight handicappers, or slightly more than half of the handicappers in this year's competition, have posted over/under picks, including one of this year's rookies Matty_Ice (or "Mr. Don't Call Me Matt Ryan!"). The rookie, who is a die-hard fan of the Miami Hurricanes first and then the NY Giants second, is surprisingly tied with Too Tall Tommy for the second-most over/under selections posted this season, with each handicapper having made eight over/under selections apiece. But it's Vikings17 who has the most over/under picks so far this season after posting 10 overall over/under picks. The rest of this year's over/under handicappers include a handful of participants who dabble in over/under picks on a yearly basis but nothing to the extent that TCU and Vikings17 have selected over/under selections in recent years. Specifically, those outliers who parsley play over/under selections on a yearly basis are 7mick7, dbucc, Driveline, Theopholius, and more recently, Kr@tos, who is now in his second season handicapping the competition. So, who's faring the best with this year's over/under selections? Of the eight handicappers who have played over/under selections this season, the answer as to who has the best over/under record is a shocker. It's Theopholis! No, it's not a misprint. What follows next is a standings, of sorts, of the best over/under handicappers based on their respective over/under records: Theopholis 2-0-0 (win% 1.000), Vikings17 4-6-0 (.400), Matty_Ice 2-6-0 (.250), TCU 1-7-0 (.125), Driveline 0-1-0 (.000), Kr@tos 0-1-0 (.000), and 7mick7 0-3-0 (.000). Ironically, over/under selection were not incorporated into the Bookie Challenge competition until Challenge year #3, and was only implemented at the behest of Driveline, who lobbied for over/under selections to become part of the Challenge competition in the off-season after Challenge year #2, but nowadays Driveline hardly ever chooses over/under picks within his weekly selections. And who can blame him, right? Especially not this season in which selecting over/under picks have been nothing more than dying propositions.


WHO'S HOT AND WHO'S NOT
WHO'S HOT: Biased Nihilist

It has been well documented over the years in the competitions' weekly reviews how the Biased Nihilist has dominated the Bookie Challenge's all-time records, and he not only owns the eye-popping all-time records but also the uniquely rare all-time records. So it should not come as a major surprise this weekend that the Nihilist tied an all-time record for winning back-to-back weeks-won, of which the Nihilist now shares the consecutive weeks-won record with six other handicappers of whom have two consecutive weeks-won apiece: Vikings17 (Challenge yr #14), Driveline (yr #12), Blitzkrieg (yr #6), CarolinaNYD (yr #4 and #1), rexkramer (yr #4), and LtFrankDrebben (yr #3). Regardless, it's a given that the Corozal Kid (aka the Nihilist) is not going to be satisfied being tied all-time for the weeks-won record with six other participants, and so one has to know that the Nihilist will be super focused this upcoming weekend to set the new all-time record of three-straight weeks-won. The Nihilist eloquently said ahead of this week's handicapping action that "I earned every all-time record that I presently have, which is a boat-load of them, so who better than me to add another all-time record to the litany of all-time records that I already own? You know, some people in the Challenge competition are so lucky that they back into all-time records, but me? ME?! I take down all-time records as if I were picking fruit from a low-hanging branch. That's right, I'm the Greatest Handicapper of All-Time--I SHOOK UP THE WORLD!"

WHO'S NOT: 7mick7

Wait a damn minute. Wasn't 7mick7 supposed to take his rookie recruit, Kennypie86, his nephew no less, under his wing and teach the greenhorn a thing or two about the Bookie Challenge competition? After all, 7mick7 had just secured his first-ever Bookie Challenge championship just two years ago (Challenge year #13), so if anybody could teach the rookie the ropes--it would be 7mick7, right? But no, when it comes to 7mick7 trying to teach Kennypie86 how to win in the unique Bookie Challenge competition, instead we have been treated to a screwed-up sequel to the movie "Bad Teacher". Some might want to call the Challenge sequel "Bad Teacher Don't Know What The Fuck He's Doing" (nor does the student, for that matter). But if there is one good thing to take away from this sorry-ass story is that Mick Balls (aka 7mick7) is a gracious son-of-a-bitch for letting his nephew off the hook, meaning that Mick Balls--by some arcane right-of-passage--replaces the "Ken Doll (Barbie's Lover)" in this egregious segment of the Bookie Challenge's weekly review, if only for a week. What's funny is that the weekly dishonor should be, by all rights, a family affair because both handicappers are trying to outdo each other to see who's the worst handicapper in the league after three weeks of this year's competition. For starters, Kennypie's two goose eggs and 7mick7's one goose egg combined to tally half the league's amount of goose eggs for the year (their 3 eggs vs the league's 6 eggs). Secondly, both handicappers are at the bottom of the barrel when it comes to having the league's worst best-bet records and corresponding win percentages. Mick Balls has the worst best-bet tally in the league (1-5-0 win% .167), while his kin has the second-worst best-bet numbers in the Challenge competition (1-3-0 win% .250). Actually, when thinking about it, 7mick7 fully deserves to replace Kennypie86 as the week's WHO'S NOT HOT handicapper, seeing as he's the only one who goose-egged from the Challenge field this past weekend. Speaking of which, it makes one wonder what's going to be the next lesson 7mick7 tries to teach his nephew: "How To Stay Humble When You're Getting Your Ass Kicked in the Bookie Challenge Competition."?


POINT STANDINGS (Thru Week #3)
Total Pts Participant Best Bet Record Win % Weeks Won Exact Scores Propositional Pts 3pt Parlays 6pt Parlays Perfectas Goose Eggs Golden Goose-Eggs Wins in Parlays
13 pts B.Nihilist* 4-2-0 .667 2 0 0 1pt(x3) 3 0 1 0 0 0 6
8 pts Vikings17* 2-4-0 ..333 1 5pt(x1) 0 1pt(x1) 6 0 0 0 0 0 2
7 pts Kr@tos 4-1-1 .800 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 4
7 pts Driveline* 4-2-0 .667 0 0 2pt(x1) 1pt(x1) 3 0 0 0 0 0 4
5 pts Blitzkrieg 4-2-0 .667 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 1 0 0 0 0 0 5
5 pts Jets69 4-2-0 .667 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 1 0 0 0 1 0 4
5 pts dbucc 2-4-0 .333 0 0 0 1pt(x3) 3 0 0 0 0 0 4
4 pts DawgPound 4-2-0 .667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5
4 pts Matty_Ice* 4-2-0 .667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
4 pts Theopholis 3-1-0 .750 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
3 pts HOFCityKid 3-3-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 3
3 pts TCU* 3-2-1 .600 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
3 pts jcvike28 2-4-0 .333 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 1 0 0 0 1 0 4
2 pts 7mick7* 1-5-0 .167 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 1 0 0 0 1 0 3
1 pts Kennypie86* 1-3-0 .250 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 2
Statistics in BOLD denotes participant leads league in statistical category.
Asterisk next to participant's name denotes his membership fees have been received. Total projected jackpot: $750 (Current jackpot: $350). Projected split of jackpot: 1st place at end of playoffs $500, 2nd place at end of playoffs $100, 3rd place prize Regular season champion $100, and 4th place prize overall Top Seed from divisional seeding (Wk#8) $50.

INDIVIDUAL PICKS (NFL WEEK #3)
(Note: Participants are listed in order in which they posted their picks)
Participant Best Bets Parlay Exact Scores Propositional Picks Results >>>>> Total Pts W-L-T Week Won Exact-Scores

5pt------2pt------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt parlay 6pt parlay Perfecta Goose Egg Golden Goose-Egg Wins in Parlay
dbucc Ind-4-W
Dall-1-L
GB-7-L
NYJ+7-W
Jax-2-W
Buff 31-17--W

Det 31-27
N/A >>>>> 2 pts 1-1-0 1pt PP-1pt 2/3
Kennypie86 LAC-2½-W
TB-6½-L
Dall-1-L
KC-6-W
Balt-5-L
Buff 34-17

Blt 34-17
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
7mick7 Dall-1-L
TB-6½-L
LAC-3-L
Hou/Jax-O45-L
Phil-3-W
Buff 34-17

Blt 31-17
N/A >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GE 1/3
Kr@tos Minn-3-W
Ind-4-W
GB-7-L
LAC-3-L
Pitts-2-W
Buff 34-24

Blt 35-31
N/A >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 1/3
Jets69 KC-6-W
Minn-3-W
Pitts-2-W
LAC-3-L
Dall-1-L
Buff 31-16--W

Blt 27-20
N/A >>>>> 3 pts 2-0-0 1pt PP-1pt 1/3
Matty_Ice LAC-2½-W
Det/Blt-O52½-W
NYG+6-L
GB-7-L
LV/Was-U45-L
Buff 33-16

Det 40-38
N/A >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 0/3
jcvike28 LAC-2½-W
TB-6½-L
Dall-1-L
KC-6-W
Balt-5-L
Buff 34-17

Blt 31-24
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
DawgPound Buff-12-L
Wash-3½-W
Cle+7-W
Pitts-2-W
LAC-3-L
Buff 27-17

Blt 33-30
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
Theopholis Dal/Chi-U50½-W
Pitts-1½-W
GB-7DQ
Den+3DQ
par-DQ
Buff 29-21--W

Blt 28-24
N/A >>>>> 3 pts 2-0-0 1pt PP-1pt DQ'd
Blitzkrieg Phil-3½-W
Wash-3½-W
KC-6-W
Pitts-2-W
Balt-5-L
Buff 37-16

Blt 27-21
N/A >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 2/3
TCU Ind-4-W
TB-6½-L
Dal/Chi-O51-L
GB/Cle-U42-W
Det/Blt-U53-L
Buff 34-24

Blt 26-24
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
Driveline Minn-3-W
Wash-3½-W
LAC-3-L
Ari+3-W
NYJ+7-W
Buff 31-17--W

Blt 31-27
N/A >>>>> 3 pts 2-0-0 1pt PP-1pt 2/3
Vikings17 Buff-12-L
Mia/Buf-O49½-W
Hou+2-L
Dal/Chi-O51-L
Det/Blt-O53-W
Buff 37-20

Blt 37-34
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
B.Nihilist LAC-2½-W
Dall-1-L
Wash-3-W
Minn-3-W
Pitts-2-W
Buff 31-10--W

Det 31-24
N/A >>>>> 8 pts 1-1-0 WW 1pt PP-1pt 6pt W-3/3
HOF City Kid Pitts-1½-W
KC-6-W
Dall-1-L
Cin+3-L
Hou+2-L
NoPick

Det 31-27
N/A >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 0/3

FINALS BUFF 31
MIA 21
IND 41
TENN 20
CAR 30
ATL 0
WASH 41
LV 24
CLE 13
GB 10
MINN 48
CIN 10
PHIL 33
LAR 26
PITTS 21
NE 14
TB 29
NYJ 27
JAX 17
HOU 10
LAC 23
DEN 20
SEA 44
NO 13
CHI 31
DALL 14
SF 16
ARI 15
KC 22
NYG 9
DET 38
BALT 30

PREVIOUS REVIEWS Annual Special Wk#1 Wk#2