Home Message Board Pick 'em Page Picks & Results Pt Standings Wkly Composites Official Rules Awards Record Archives Handicapper Capsules
Bookie Challenge
WEEKLY REVIEW

September 18, 2026 | Issue #1 | Week #1

Parts Unknown (DP--Disassociated Press): The 16th annual Bookie Challenge competition came sprinting out of the gates in its season-opening outing of week #1. Four handicappers--the Biased Nihilist, Driveline, Kr@tos, and Matty_Ice--all connected on their respective 6-point parlay combinations and each handicapper ended their respective season openers with 7-point outings apiece for the weekend. Impressively, the four 6-point parlay winners from this past weekend tied the all-time record for a Bookie Challenge field to open up a handicapping season. Back in Challenge year #5, rexkramer (7pts), 1947Lifer (PF-PERFECTA), Smokey McPot (PF), and redsoxdon (PF) initially established the combined handicapping feat, and in the process, the four handicappers back in Challenge year #5 were also instrumental in setting the all-time scoring record (48 pts) by a Bookie Challenge field to open up a handicapping season. This past weekend, this year's Challenge field scored 41 combined points to start off its new season, of which the 41 points scored rank third all-time behind the aforementioned 48 points in Challenge year #5 and the combined 47 points tallied in Challenge year #8. But despite the very decent start by this year's Challenge field, this past weekend's season opener for the 16th annual Bookie Challenge competition was not all peaches and cream. On the contrary, the Challenge field could have improved on its 41 points it scored in this year's opener if only a handful of handicappers would have knocked down some points for their exact-score predictions. Incredibly, however, even though this year's Challenge field started this season with its highest number of members (19) since Challenge year #9 (also 19 members), not one handicapper within the Challenge field connected on any exact-score points, and that egregious failure included both of the exact-score games for the opening weekend (UPDATE! after Thursday night's first exact-score selections for week #2, this year's Challenge field has yet to record an exact-score point). For the record, the last time a Challenge field missed its exact-scores for an entire weekend occurred in week #15 of last year's competition. In addition to the exact-score misses in week #1, five handicappers--dbucc, Blitzkrieg, TCU, Hall-of-Fame City Kid, and rookie Brooklyn211--all goose egged their respective handicapping starts to this year's competition.

As it concerned the four 6-point parlay winners from this past weekend, the Biased Nihilist continued his dominance of connecting on the most all-time 6-point parlay winners in the history of the Bookie Challenge competition after he became the first handicapper this season to knock down a 6-point parlay winner. The Nihilist rebounded from losing his first best-bet of the season, of which was the Thursday-night game in week #1 that was played in Australia between San Francisco and the LA Rams (the Nihilist had chosen the Rams -3½, his favorite NFL team). But on the ensuing Sunday, the self-proclaimed Greatest Handicapper of All Time blasted out the year's first 6-point parlay hit after the first slate of early games became finals on the first Sunday of this NFL season. The 6-point parlay winner by the Nihilist was his 40th all-time regular-season 6-point parlay hit, and when including 6-point parlay hits for the postseason, the Nihilist has now pounded out 46 all-time career parlay winners for the regular season and postseason combined. Just to get an idea as to why the Nihilist is the King of 6-point parlay hits, the next all-time totals of 6-point parlay hits by active handicappers who qualify for all-time records is 27 6-point parlay winners, of which the 27 all-time parlay winners have been produced by three separate handicappers (7mick7, jcvike28, and Blitzkrieg). The Nihilist produced his winning 3-team parlay combination by choosing all favorites--Buffalo (-2) over Houston, Pittsburgh (-3) over Atlanta, and Cincinnati (-3) over Tampa Bay.

Also hitting a 6-point parlay on the opening Sunday of the season was 2nd-year veteran Matty_Ice, who completed his parlay trifecta at the end of the second slate of games on Sunday. But more importantly, Matty_Ice finally got off the schneid and drilled his first-career 6-point parlay winner. Also known by his Bookie Challenge moniker as the "Handicapping Hurricane" because he loves the Miami Hurricanes in college football, Matty_Ice was able to knock down his first-ever 6-point parlay winner thanks in large part to three superb selections. In the first slate of games on this past Sunday, Matty_Ice chose the game between Tampa Bay and Cincinnati to go over the pointspread total of 51 total points. Subsequently, the game went easily over the total after the Bengals beat the Buccaneers by a final of 33-27 (60 total pts scored). The winning parlay pick in the early slate of Sunday's games enabled Matty_Ice to enter the second slate of Sunday's games needing the Las Vegas Raiders (-3) to cover over the Miami Dolphins, and also for the same game to stay under the scoring total of 42 combined points in order for Matty_Ice to hit parlay paydirt for the first time ever. As it turned out, and much to the delight of the "Handicapping Hurricane", he indeed was able to secure his first all-time 6-point parlay hit after the Kirk Cousins-led Raiders covered the -3 pointspread over the Dolphins by defeating the "Fish" 27-13. However, Matty_Ice got really lucky that the game stayed under the 42-point total (27-to-13=40pts). In fact, just to show how a Bookie Challenge handicapper sometimes needs a little luck to connect on a big parlay winner, the Miami Dolphins' place kicker Riley Patterson missed a chip-shot 41-yard field goal after a critical Dolphins' drive had stalled at the Raiders' 23-yard line with just 11 seconds left to play in the 3rd quarter. If Patterson connects on his 41-yard FG attempt, Matty_Ice would have suffered an excruciating loss of his parlay combination, but instead the two-year Challenge veteran ended his opening weekend with a big-time outing, his best ever in his nascent Bookie Challenge career.

After the Biased Nihilist and Matty_Ice recorded the competition's first 6-point parlay winners of the season on the opening Sunday of the 16th annual Bookie Challenge competition, the Bookie Challenge had to wait until the conclusion of this year's first Monday night game between Denver and Kansas City to become a final before the competition could see if two more 6-point parlay hits were going to be won on the opening weekend. Specifically, both Driveline and Kr@tos had entered Monday night's game with each handicapper needing just one more parlay winner within their respective 3-team combos for each handicapper to keep pace with the Biased Nihilist (7 pts) and Matty_Ice (7 pts). In the case of Driveline, he needed the game between the Broncos and the Chiefs to stay under the pointspread total of 44 points, while Kr@tos needed the Chiefs to cover a -3 pointspread over the Broncos. Much to the relief of both handicappers, the Chiefs throttled the Broncos handedly 31-10, of which the huge victory by the Chiefs allowed Kr@tos to easily win his 6-point parlay combination. However, the two-time Bookie Challenge champion Driveline had to sweat out his parlay hopes as the combined 41 total points of the Monday night game just barely stayed under the pointspread total of 44 points. In any event, the 6-point parlay hit by Driveline was his all-time 23rd parlay winner for regular season handicapping, and it was his 25th overall 6-point parlay winner when including his two all-time 6-point parlay hits he has knocked down in his postseasons. As it pertains to Kr@tos, he notched his 5th all-time 6-point parlay in just his third year of handicapping the Bookie Challenge competition. By connecting on a 6-point parlay hit to open up this season, the "Handicapping God of War", as Kr@tos is popularly known by his main Bookie Challenge moniker, has now tallied a 6-point parlay hit in each of his first-three seasons (to include this season). Oddly, in last year's Bookie Challenge competition, Kr@tos belted out a rare 3-point parlay winner in the first week of last year's handicapping season. And although there have been many handicappers who have hit 6-point parlays on different opening days in the history of the competition, after connecting on his 6-point parlay hit in week #1 of this season, the "Handicapping God of War" became the first handicapper in the history of the Bookie Challenge competition to open consecutive seasons with a 3-point parlay hit and then a 6-point parlay hit. That all-time record is likely to never be broken because few handicappers ever attempt 3-point parlay hits during the Bookie Challenge's regular seasons. To be exact, in the previous 15 years of the Bookie Challenge competition, only eight 3-point parlay winners have ever been won in the history of the Bookie Challenge's regular seasons.


WEEKLY ODDS AND ENDS: THE HANDICAPPING HODGEPODGE

  • A 4-WAY TIE FOR 1ST PLACE AFTER WEEK #1?...YEAH SO, GAME ON!: After the Biased Nihilist, Matty_Ice, Kr@tos, and Driveline each ended the opening week of the season in a 4-way tie for first place in the season's first point standings, the eight-week rat race to this year's divisional seeding has gotten off to an intriguing start. For starters, because 19 overall members are competing in this year's handicapping competition, all four prizes from this year's Gold-Pressed Latinum jackpot have increased, including the 4th-place prize to be awarded to whomever captures this season's overall top seed at the conclusion of week #8's handicapping action. The 4th-place prize was incorporated just two seasons ago and the payouts for the first-two seasons was $50 to the first-ever top-seed winners. Blitzkrieg had won the first-ever top-seed prize ($50) in Challenge year #14 and the Nihilist ($50) won the top-seed prize in last year's competition (yr #15). However, with a record-setting total jackpot of $950 being established for this year's competition, the 4th-place prize to be awarded for seizing this year's top seed will be a noteworthy sum of $100. With that being said, the Nihilist, Matty_Ice, Kr@tos, and Driveline are all licking their chops even though there is still a long ways to go before week #8's divisional seeding takes place. Still, though, the 4-way tie for first place in the point standings is a great start for the four aforementioned handicappers, and if anything, the tie almost assures that the competition is headed for its most exciting dog-eat-dog battle to ever be fought for an overall number-one top seed.


  • WEEKLY TICKER ...........KEEP AN EYE ON KR@TOS: After Kr@tos opened up his 3rd Bookie Challenge competition with a 7-point outing, he is starting to build a reputation in the league for having the moxie and doggedness to become a top contender in the Bookie Challenge, especially in the regular season. Now granted, Kr@tos completely collapsed in his 1st postseason of his rookie season from two years ago, but in that first regular season he hit 3 6-pt parlay hits and also won the Red Zone divisional title. In his sophomore season of Challenge year #15, the "Handicapping God of War" produced a 2nd-consecutive winning best-bet record after going 21-16-1 (Win% .568) en route to winning a second divisional title (Hail Mary division).........THIS YEAR'S ROOKIE CROP GETS OFF TO A HO-HUM START: This year's rookie class that consists of KingDarsh, Jonnybucs, JamesGang, and Brooklyn211 went a combined 3-5-0 with their collective best-bets, with Brooklyn211 producing an opening-day goose egg.................



7
CHALLENGE FIELD: WEEKLY COMBINED STATS AND HAPPENINGS
WEEKLY RESULTS (Thru Wk #1)
Week/YTD Best Bet Record Win % Total Pts Exact-Scores

5pt-------2pt---------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt Parlays 6pt Parlays Perfectas Goose Eggs Golden Goose Eggs Wins Within Parlay Consensus Picks
Week #1 17-18-3 .486 41 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 5 0 36 consensus 1-1-0
W% .500
YTD 17-18-3 .486 41 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 5 0 36 consensus 1-1-0
W% .500
Single-Season
Records
504-414-33
(Yr#5)
.549 (Yr#5) 1087 (Yr#8) x4
(Yrs #8
& #6)
x5
Yr#15
X44
(Yr#14)
241
(Yr#9)
9
(Yr#7)
56 (Yr#8) 19
(Yr#8)
92 (Yr#8) 23 (Yr#4) 631 (Yr#8) 16-8-2
W% .667 (Yr#6)

  • APART FROM CONNECTING ON FOUR 6-PT PARLAY HITS, THE CHALLENGE FIELD GETS OFF TO SUBPAR BEST-BET START: This year's Bookie Challenge field produced a spirited handicapping season opener after it knocked down an all-time record-tying four 6-point parlay winners. However, when it came to its combined best-bets for the first weekend of the season, the Challenge field only recorded a 17-18-3 best-bet tally, which was only good for an underachieving .486 winning percentage of its best bets. Worst yet, the field egregiously went 0-for-37 with its combined exact-score selections (OUCH!)



WHO'S HOT AND WHO'S NOT
WHO'S HOT: The Biased Nihilist

Leave it to the self-proclaimed "Greatest Handicapper of All-Time" to once again show off his propensity for being rated as one of the Bookie Challenge's top performers. This past weekend the Nihilist opened up his handicapping campaign with a best-bet loser after his LA Rams let him down big time (LA lost to SF 27-7). If the Nihilist would have not scored a point for the rest of the weekend, he would have seen his all-time consecutive scoring-record bite the dust, and he would have also seen his all-time consecutive streak without producing a scoreless outing come to a screeching halt as well. But if there's one thing the "Corozal Kid" does not lack is a snooty confidence, and on the Saturday before this season's opening Sunday, the Corozal Kid layed it on thick, saying that he was going to score to save his streaks. Then...wait for it...wait for it...BAM!...the Nihilist talked the talk and walked the walk and won his remaining best bet for the weekend and also connected on yet another 6-point parlay hit. With the handicapping heroics in the books, the Nihilist ran both of his ongoing record-setting consecutive streaks to 31 straight outings. That's 31 straight outings that the Nihilist has scored at least one point and 31 straight outings that the Nihilist did not have a scoreless outing, meaning no goose eggs nor golden goose eggs. The consecutive streaks started after week #13 of Challenge year #14 (or from the 2nd leg of that year's Turkey Shoot), and continued through the last nine weeks of Challenge year #14's competition. Amazingly, the streak was maintained for 21 straight outings in last year's competition (Challenge yr #15) and is still ongoing after the start to this year's competition. Oh, actually the streaks have been guaranteed to go through week #2 of this season, for the Nihilist won his Thursday-night best-bet opener for week #2 (Buff -5½ over Det), of which his streaks have now been officially extended to 32 overall weekends in a row. And God only knows how much longer the Nihilist's consecutive streaks are going to run roughshod over the rest of the league. But if the Nihilist had his way...oh Lord, help us.

WHO'S NOT: Jonnybucs

By all rights, it should be the rookie who hails by the username Brooklyn211 who should be debuting in this WHO'S NOT HOT HANDICAPPER section, but it's going to be another rookie who'll get this year's worst write up, meaning Jonnybucs. Here's why: even though "The Brooklyn Dodger" couldn't dodge a career-opening goose egg outing, and conversely Jonnybucs managed to score one point in his greenhorn debut, it's Jonnybucs who nevertheless gets the nod for being this past weekend's most fucked up handicapper. The old saying goes "like father like son" but we're going to go with "like son, like father". You see, Kennypie86 is Jonnybucs' stepson, and in his rookie start to last year's competition--Kennypie86 (also known by his Bookie Challenge moniker as the "Ken Doll") posted his exact-score selection for the Thursday night game that opened up last year's competition. The only problem was that the ken Doll went to the Buccaneers season opener last year and proceeded to get inebriated and didn't post the rest of his Bookie Challenge picks for the weekend, including his Super Bowl selections. Now I'm under the impression, especially after Jonnybucs had his Super Bowl selections from his rookie debut of this past weekend DISQUALIFIED, that something is definitely wrong with this father-and-son tag team. Yep, w-w-what had h-h-happened was that rookie Jonnybucs edited his original set of Super Bowl picks and changed one of his selected teams from Philadelphia to Denver. So, yes, "like son, like father". Maybe the rest of the league needs to say a prayer for Jonnybucs--I don't know--maybe we ought to pray that Jonnybucs disqualified Super Bowl picks doesn't come back to bite him in his "Buc"-naked a-a-ass. Rookies, man, rookies--go figure!


POINT STANDINGS (Thru Week #1)
Total Pts Participant Best Bet Record Win % Weeks Won Exact Scores Propositional Pts 3pt Parlays 6pt Parlays Perfectas Goose Eggs Golden Goose-Eggs Wins in Parlays
7 Pts B.Nihilist 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 3
7 Pts Driveline 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 3
7 Pts Kr@tos 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 3
7 Pts Matty_Ice 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 3
2 Pts catman23 2-0-0 1.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
2 Pts Vikings17 2-0-0 1.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
2 Pts Jets69 2-0-0 1.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
1 Pts 7mick7 1-0-1 1.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
1 Pts jcvike28 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
1 Pts KingDarsh 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
1 Pts DawgPound 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
1 Pts JamesGang 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
1 Pts Jonnybucs 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
1 Pts Kennypie86 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 Pts Blitzkrieg 0-1-1 .000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2
0 Pts Brooklyn211 0-2-0 .000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2
0 Pts HOF City Kid 0-2-0 .000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2
0 Pts TCU 0-2-0 .000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2
0 Pts dbucc 0-2-0 .000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1
Statistics in BOLD denotes participant leads league in statistical category.
*Asterisk next to participant's name denotes participant's Latinum has been received. Total projected jackpot: $950 (Current jackpot: $700). Projected splits of jackpot: 1st-place prize at end of playoffs $500, 2nd-place prize at end of playoffs $200, 3rd-place prize Regular-season champion $150, and 4th-place prize overall Top Seed from divisional seeding (Wk#8) $100.

INDIVIDUAL PICKS (NFL WEEK #1)
(Note: Participants are listed in order in which they posted their picks)
Participant Best Bets Parlay Exact Scores Propositional Picks Results >>>>> Total Pts W-L-T Week Won Exact-Scores

5pt------2pt------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt parlay 6pt parlay Perfecta Goose Egg Golden Goose-Egg Wins in Parlay
dbucc Sea-3-T
LAR-3½-L
TB/Cin-O51-W
Hou+2-L
Den+3-L
Sea 27-17

Den 24-19
SB: LAR def Balt >>>>> O pts 0-1-1 GE 1/3
JamesGang LAR-3½-L
Jax-8½-W
LAC-10-L
Buff-2-W
Det-7-L
Sea 23-20

KC 23-20
SB: Chi def Buff >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
Jets69 NYJ+2-W
KC-2½-W
Balt-3-W
Det-7-L
Hou+2-L
Sea 24-21

KC 21-17
SB: Sea def Buff >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 1/3
Kennypie86 SF+3½-W
TB+3½-L
LAC-10-L
NYG+3-W
Mia/LV-O42-L
Sea 27-20

KC 24-20
SB: TB def Cin >>>>> 0 pts 1-1-0 1/3
catman23 Cin-3½-W
Balt-3½-W
Dall-3-L
Chi-3-W
Buff-2-W
Sea 14-7

Den 21-14
SB: SF def Den >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 2/3
Matty_Ice Balt-3½-W
LAR-3½-L
LV-3-W
Mia/LV-U42-W
TB/Cin-O51-W
Sea 27-17

NoPick
SB: LAR def Balt >>>>> 7 pts 1-1-0 6pt W-3/3
7mick7 Sea-3-T
Cin-3½-W
Pitts-3-W
Det-7-L
Minn-2-W
Sea 21-17

KC 24-20
SB: Det def Cin >>>>> 1 pts 1-0-1 2/3
Jonnybucs SF+3½-W
TB+3½-L
Phil-6-L
GB+2-L
Buff-2-W
Sea 23-21

KC 24-21
SB: TB def Phil
DQ (edited pick to change Phil to Den)
>>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
Brooklyn211 LAC-9½-L
Det-7-L
Buff-2-W
Tenn-2-L
Jax-9-W
Sea 31-23

KC 21-20
SB: Buff def LAR >>>>> O pts 0-2-0 GE 2/3
DawgPound Chi-3-W
Det-7-L
Cle+9-L
KC-3-W
Dall-3-L
Sea 24-21

KC 24-20
SB: LAR def Buff >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
Driveline Pitts-3-W
Ind+3½-L
Minn-2-W
Buff-2-W
Den/KC-U44-W
Sea 27-16

Den 17-16
SB: Buff def LAR >>>>> 7 pts 1-1-0 6pt W-3/3
TCU Phil-5½-L
Dal/NYG-O48½-L
LAC-10-L
Buff-2-W
Den/KC-U44-W
Sea 31-21

KC 21-20
SB: Buff def Det >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GE 2/3
B.Nihilist LAR-3½-L
KC-2½-W
Cin-3-W
Pitts-3-W
Buff-2-W
Sea 24-20

KC 27-20
SB: LAR def Buff >>>>> 7 pts 1-1-0 6pt W-3/3
Kr@tos Buf/Hou-O44½-W
Det-7-L
Minn-2-W
LV-3-W
KC-3-W
NE 31-24

KC 27-17
SB: Minn def NE >>>>> 7 pts 1-1-0 6pt W-3/3
KingDarsh Det-7-L
NYJ/Ten-U39½-W
Pitts-3-W
Dall-3-L
Balt-3-W
Sea 24-21

Den 27-14
SB: Den def LAR >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
HOF City Kid Cle+8½-L
Dall-3-L
Pitts-3-W
KC-3-W
Phil-6-L
Sea 27-21

KC 27-21
SB: SF def KC >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GE 2/3
Blitzkrieg Sea-3-T
GB+1½-L
Chi-3-W
Buff-2-W
Tenn-2-L
Sea 24-20

KC 21-20
SB: Buff def SF >>>>> 0 pts 0-1-1 GE 2/3
Vikings17 SF+3½-W
Minn--1½-W
Pitts-3-W
Det-7-L
Jax-9-W
Sea 30-23

Den 23-20
SB: LAR def Buff >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 2/3
jcvike28 Phil-5½-L
LV-3½-W
Pitts-3-W
Hou+2-L
Minn-2-W
Sea 24-17

KC 24-20
SB: LAR def Buff >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3

FINALS SEA 13
NE 10
SF 27
LAR 7
JAX 34
CLE 10
CINN 33
CIN 27
BALT 41
IND 23
ATL
PITTS
BUFF 36
HOU 31
CHI 59
CAR 37
NYJ 23
TENN 10
DET 31
NO 30
ARI 26
LAC 14
LV 27
MIA 13
PHIL 24
WASH 22
MINN 39
GB 22
NYG 28
DALL 20
KC 31
DEN 10

PREVIOUS REVIEWS N/A