Home Message Board Pick 'em Page Picks & Results Pt Standings Wkly Composites Official Rules Awards Record Archives Handicapper Capsules
Bookie Challenge
WEEKLY REVIEW

October 9, 2025 | Issue #6 | Week #5

Parts Unknown (DP--Disassociated Press): The mostly mundane start to this season continued to haunt the Challenge field this past weekend. In short, the Challenge's fifth weekend of the season this past weekend was a big, fat disappointment. No 6-point parlay hits were nailed down, nobody won the weekend outright, and as a consequence, no major changes took place in the competition's point standings, or none that resulted in any large separations of points within the standings. As a matter of fact, the Challenge field's outing of this past weekend was so off-kilter that not a single exact-score point was recorded, which obviously meant that dbucc's streak of four weeks in a row with an exact-score winner came to a screeching halt. Overall, only three handicappers--Vikings17, Driveline, and Blitzkrieg--were able to register two-point outings after each handicapper won both of their respective best bets. As it concerned Driveline, his 2-point outing enabled him to crack into the one of the top-four seeds in thr standings. More specifically, the "Fisher of Winners" (aka Driveline) was able to launch himself into the third top seed in the standings, of which Driveline's rise into the top-four seeds slightly dropped dbucc from the third top seed to the fourth top seed. After the weekend ran its course, the top-four seeds in the standings belonged to the Biased Nihilist (20pts/#1 seed), Vikings17 (15pts/#2 seed), Driveline (9pts/#3 seed), and dbucc (also 9pts/but #4 seed after losing best-bet tiebreaker to Driveline.

Entering this past weekend, the rookie Matty_Ice was easily outshining this season's other rookie, Kennypie86, for the early nod to be honored with this year's Rookie-of-the-Year award. In fact, to his credit, Matty_Ice had correctly posted every one of his selections throughout the first-four weeks of this year's handicapping contest. And because of his fine effort to grasp the correct procedures of the competition, he was rewarded--so to speak--by ending week #4 in the 4th slot of the point standings, albeit by tiebreakers over both Driveline and Kr@tos (all three had 7 pts apiece). But what the hell got into Matty_Ice this past weekend won't be known unless he comes out and tells the rest of the participants why he failed to post any picks whatsoever on this past weekend, with the exception of his exact-score pick for the Thursday night game. Just so everybody will know, the Nihilist saw Matty_Ice log in on the message board for over 30 minutes this past Sunday morning, but he then logged out without posting any selections, which happens a lot on Sunday mornings, to mean that some handicappers log in and out a few times before finally logging in and posting weekly selections. However, after Matty_Ice logged out of the message board, he never logged back in to make his weekly picks. His posting snafu was costly too, because his failure to post any picks resulted in him falling four slots in the point standings. from the number-four slot in the standings and down to eight place overall.

At the present moment, nobody within the point standings should start to panic just yet, especially when it comes to qualifying as a third or fourth top seed in the standings. Right now, the standings are so closely knit that even Kennypie86 has time to turn things around and qualify as either a third seed or fourth seed at this year's divisional seeding. On the flip side, time is starting to run out, and those handicappers who are presently occupying the top-four seeds in the standings are some of the league's toughest handicappers, meaning the Biased Nihilist (20pts), Vikings17 (15pts), Driveline (9pts), and dbucc (9pts). All four handicappers possess the moxie to maintain their respective top seeded slots. More importantly, all four handicappers are well aware what it means to start a divisional race at the helm of one of the four divisions. So the rat race that is taking place over the course of the next three weekends to see who snares one of the top four seeds is a highly critical one.

Better yet, winning the overall number-one top seed at a divisional seeding is a really big deal. To begin with, the eventual number-one top seed will pocket $50, or this season's first cash prize. In addition, the number-one top seed will be seeded with two of the lowest seeded handicappers in the league. Also, let's not forget that winning the number-one top seed will include one less participant in the division to worry about. Yes sir, there are only three weeks left until this year's divisional seeding takes place. In other words, stay tuned!


WEEKLY ODDS AND ENDS: THE HANDICAPPING HODGEPODGE

  • NEAR-MISSES OF 6-POINT PARLAY HITS DEPRIVES FIVE PARTICIPANTS FROM MAKING SEASON-CHANGING PERFORMANCES IN WEEK #5: Sometimes, to be successful in the Bookie Challenge competition, one game in a parlay combination can make a big difference--especially when only one game in one's parlay combination ruins the entire parlay combo. This past weekend, five handicappers--Vikings17, TCU, dbucc, DawgPound, and HOF City Kid--felt the agony of losing a crucial 6-point parlay winner because of just one game. In the case of Vikings17, who missed his parlay pick of NE/Buffalo to go over 50 points cost him PERFECTA outing and also the overall lead of the Bookie Challenge standings. Two participants, DawgPound and HOF City Kid--both ended up goose egging their respective weekends after Cleveland (+3) loss versus Minnesota derailed his parlay winner and the Hall-of-Fame City Kid saw the LA Chargers (-3) versus Washington foil his 6-point parlay hit. The remaining two handicappers, TCU and dbucc, each avoided goose egg outings after each handicapper connected on one respective best bet apiece, but they both still felt the pain after losing their respective 6-point parlay combination because of one parlay pick. Too Tall Tommy lost his parlay winner after the game between the Raiders and Colts failed to go over 48 points (Indy won 40-6), and dbucc saw his 6-point parlay winner bite the dust after Arizona (-7) got bitch-slapped by Tennessee.


  • WEEKLY TICKER.................If it were not for a couple of Blitzkrieg's near misses of 6-point parlay combinations, he could possibly be leading the overall competition instead of the Biased Nihilist. As it stands right now, Blitzkrieg owns the top best-bet record in the league, which is a 7-3-0 best-bet tally that factors out to a highly impressive .700 win percentage. What's more, after winning both of his best bets this past weekend, the Snowman and the Falcon (aka Blitzkrieg) is one point behind both Driveline and dbucc for occupying top seed in the standings .....................The Challenge field has yet to record a PERFECTA outing after the first five weeks of this year's competition, but their PERFECTA futility comes with a precedent. In Challenge year #3, the field did not register a PERFECTA outing until week #14 of that season ......................This past weekend saw a flurry of bone-headed posting blunders ruin several handicappers' outings: As already mentioned, Matty_Ice mysteriously failed to post his weekly picks, Kr@tos failed to beat Sunday's posting deadline and had his parlay combo and exact-score pick for Monday night disqualified, and Kennypie86 only posted one best bet and had his entire parlay combo disqualified after he chose Cleveland (+3 vs Minny) but the game had already started because it was an early London game.


CHALLENGE FIELD: WEEKLY COMBINED STATS AND HAPPENINGS
WEEKLY RESULTS (Thru Week #5)
Week/YTD Best Bet Record Win % Total Pts Exact-Scores

5pt-------2pt---------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt Parlays 6pt Parlays Perfectas Goose Eggs Golden Goose Eggs Wins Within Parlay Consensus Picks
Week #5 13-14-0 .481 13 x1 x1 x5 12 0 0 0 5 1 15 consensus 1-0-0
W% 1.000
YTD 66-75-2 .468 114 x2 x2 x18 32 1 2 0 14 1 87 consensus 3-3-0
W% .500
Single-Season
Records
504-414-33
(Yr#5)
.549 (Yr#5) 1087 (Yr#8) x4
(Yrs #8
& #6)
x2
Yr#14
X44
(Yr#14)
241
(Yr#9)
9
(Yr#7)
56 (Yr#8) 19
(Yr#8)
92 (Yr#8) 23 (Yr#4) 631 (Yr#8) 16-8-2
W%.667 (Yr#4)

  • THE CHALLENGE FIELD AFTER WEEK #5: "OH, WOE ARE WE!" This year's Bookie Challenge field, with the exception of a handful of its handicappers, is having a hard time beating the NFL pointspreads. Granted, it's a really tough proposition to consistently beat the Vegas Crocodiles at their own game, but this year's Challenge field can't seem to get going, as if it has run off the road because of a heavy fog. Just to give everybody in the competition an idea of how badly the handicappers within the Challenge field are struggling to find their handicapping mojo, this past weekend this year's field set a new all-time record for producing the least amount of 6-point parlay hits to start off the first five weeks of a Challenge competition. The previous record for the lowest number of 6-point parlay hits through the first-five weeks of a regular season was just three parlay winners, of which was accomplished twice before (in Challenge years' #14 and #3). But after this past weekend, the field has only recorded two 6-point parlay hits after the first-five weeks of this season, with both of the hits coming courtesy of the Biased Nihilist, who hit back-to-back 6-point parlay winners in week #3 and week #4 of this season. Moreover, the lack of any 6-point parlay winners over this past weekend, has directly affected the Field's overall scoring for this past weekend, as the field only mustered 13 overall points for its outing. The 13-point output was the lowest since week #2 of last year's competition, of which that year's Challenge field also tallied a dispiriting 13 overall points.


WHO'S HOT AND WHO'S NOT
WHO'S HOT: Not Applicable

It's rare to see this segment not occupied with a WHO'S HOT HANDICAPPER of the week, but here we are. This past weekend, no handicapper in the competition did anything extraordinary to merit the weekly honor for being the HOTTEST HANDICAPPER in the league. Maybe next week, huh?

WHO'S NOT: Kennypie86

Don't be surprised to see Kennypie86 featured in this segment of the weekly review for the fourth time this season (out of 5 times/weeks). To be brutally honest, the "Ken Doll" has screwed up his rookie season like no rookie before him has ever messed up. In fact, the Bookie Challenge thought of a way to pick up his spirits so that he can be more focused, you know, stop getting his parlay combos disqualified because of taking games that have already started, such as those games having been played overseas--but the competition couldn't find a way to appease the Ken Doll. In fact, Kennypie's rookie debut has been so maligned that if ever the league had the dishonor for the WHO'S-NOT-HOT-HANDICAPPER of a Challenge PRESEASON, the ken Doll would be the recipient of the dishonor. Just to recap how much Kennypie has fucked up his season, check out the following handicapping transgressions that he has negotiated in his first five weeks of a Bookie Challenge competition. For starters, he's presently in dead-last place in the Challenge point standings after eking out just two pathetic points on the season. Second off, he is presently tied with the Hall-of-Fame City Kid for having laid the most goose eggs this season (3 apiece). Third off, out of the first five weeks of this season he has had only two parlay combos that he has posted correctly, meaning two of his parlay combos have been entirely disqualified and he failed to post any picks in this year's opening weekend. And lastly, he has the worst best-bet record in the league, which is a 1-6-0 record that factors out to a miniscule .143 winning percentage. However, when thinking deeper about the Ken Doll's atrocious handicapping debut, he may not be totally to blame for his horrible start, and that's because his uncle--7mick7--has not taken Kennypie under his wings and showed him the ropes of participating fully in a Challenge competition. Of course, it's up to Kennypie to read over the rules so he knows what the hell is going on. The key word in the previous sentence is "read", of which that's all Kennypie needs to do to play by the rules of the competition--is just to read the posting guidelines. But no, as simple as it sounds, the Ken Doll ain't getting it, and 7mick7 isn't helping him out any when it comes to making his nephew understand what abiding by a "posting deadline" entails.


tr>
POINT STANDINGS (Thru Week #5)
Total Pts Participant Best Bet Record Win % Weeks Won Exact Scores Propositional Pts 3pt Parlays 6pt Parlays Perfectas Goose Eggs Golden Goose-Eggs Wins in Parlays
20 pts B.Nihilist* 5-5-0 .500 3 0 0 1pt(x3) 3 0 2 0 0 0 10
15 pts Vikings17* 4-6-0 .400 1 5pt(x2) 0 1pt(x1) 11 0 0 0 0 0 6
9 pts Driveline* 6-4-0 .600 0 0 2pt(x1) 1pt(x1) 3 0 0 0 1 0 7
9 pts dbucc 5-5-0 .500 0 0 0 1pt(x4) 4 0 0 0 0 0 7
8 pts Blitzkrieg* 7-3-0 .700 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 1 0 0 0 0 0 7
8 pts Kr@tos* 5-4-1 .556 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 4
7 pts Theopholis 5-3-0 .625 0 0 0 1pt(x2) 2 0 0 0 0 0 4
7 pts Matty_Ice* 5-3-0 .625 0 0 2pt(x1) 0 2 0 0 0 1 0 3
6 pts DawgPound 6-4-0 .600 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 8
6 pts Jets69* 5-5-0 .500 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 1 0 0 0 2 0 6
6 pts TCU* 5-4-1 .556 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 5
4 pts 7mick7* 3-7-0 .300 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 1 0 0 0 1 0 6
4 pts jcvike28 2-8-0 .200 0 0 0 1pt(x2) 2 0 0 0 2 0 5
3 pts HOFCityKid 3-7-0 .300 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 6
2 pts Kennypie86* 1-6-0 .143 0 0 0 1pt(x1) 1 0 0 0 3 0 2
Statistics in BOLD denotes participant leads league in statistical category.
Asterisk next to participant's name denotes his membership fees have been received. Total projected jackpot: $750 (Current jackpot: $500). Projected split of jackpot: 1st place at end of playoffs $500, 2nd place at end of playoffs $100, 3rd place prize Regular season champion $100, and 4th place prize overall Top Seed from divisional seeding (Wk#8) $50.

INDIVIDUAL PICKS (NFL WEEK #5)
(Note: Participants are listed in order in which they posted their picks)
Participant Best Bets Parlay Exact Scores Propositional Picks Results >>>>> Total Pts W-L-T Week Won Exact-Scores

5pt------2pt------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt parlay 6pt parlay Perfecta Goose Egg Golden Goose-Egg Wins in Parlay
DawgPound LAR-8½-L
Buff--8-L
Cle+3-L
Dall-3-W
Ind-3-W
LAR 27-17

KC 27-23
N/A >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GE 2/3
jcvike28 Cle+3½-L
LAC-2½-L
Phil-3-L
Hou-2-W
Det-10-L
LAR 27-13

KC 24-20
N/A >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GE 1/3
Matty_Ice NoPick
NoPick
NoPick
NoPick
NoPick
LAR 27-13

NoPick
N/A >>>>> 0 pts GE NoPicks
TCU Dall-2½-W
Buff-8-L
LV/Ind-O48-L
Den/Phi-U44-W
Dal/NYJ-O48-W
LAR 31-17

Jax 21-20
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
Driveline Ind-6½-W
TB+3½-W
NO-2-W
Phil-3-L
NYJ+3-L
LAR 31-27

KC 24-17
N/A >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 1/3
7mick7 Phil-3½-L
Det-10½-W
Ind-7-W
Ari-7-L
LAC-3-L
LAR 27-17

KC 31-20
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
Theopholis Ind-6½-W
Ari-7½-L
Cin+10-L
Buff-8-L
Hou-2-W
LAR 27-22

KC 24-20
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
Kr@tos Ind-6½-W
LAC-2½-L
Den+3-DQ
NYJ+3-DQ
Sea-3-DQ
LAR 27-24

Jax 28-17--DQ
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 DQ'd
dbucc LAR-8½-L
Dall-2½-W
Ind-7-W
Ari-7-L
Det-10-W
LAR 30-16

KC 27-20
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
Jets69 Ind-6½-W
NYJ+2½-L
Sea-3-L
LAC-3-L
Ari-7-L
SF 23-20

KC 24-20
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 0/3
B.Nihilist Ind-6½-W KC-3½-L NYG+2-L
Det-10-W
Buff-8-L
LAR 27-14

KC 27-20
N/A >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
Vikings17 Det-10½-W
Ind-6½-W
TB/Sea-O45-W
NE/Buf-O50-L
Jax/KC-O44-W
LAR 34-17

KC 27-24
N/A >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 2/3
Kennypie86 Buff-8-L
NoPick
Cle-DQ
Dall-3-DQ
Ind-7-DQ
LAR 31-27--DQ

KC 31-24
N/A >>>>> 0 pts 0-1-0 GE DQ'd
Blitzkrieg Car+2-W
NO-2-W
Ari-7-L
KC-3-L
LAC-3-L
LAR 28-21--DQ

KC 27-24
N/A >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 0/3
HOF City Kid Phil-3½-L
Cin+10-L
TB+3-W
LAC-3-L
Dall-3-W
NoPick

KC 31-20
N/A >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GE 2/3

FINALS SF 26
LAR 23
MINN 21
CLE 17
CAR 27
MIA 24
DALL 37
NYJ 22
IND 40
LV 6
DEN 21
PHIL 17
NO 26
NYG 14
HOU 44
BALT 10
TENN 22
ARI 21
TB 38
SEA 35
DET 37
CIN 24
WASH 27
LAC 10
NE 23
BUFF 20
JAX 31
KC 28

PREVIOUS REVIEWS Annual Special Wk#1 Wk#2 Wk#3 Wk#4