| Home | Message Board | Pick 'em Page | Picks & Results | Pt Standings | Wkly Composites | Official Rules | Awards | Record Archives | Handicapper Capsules |
![]() |
Bookie Challenge WEEKLY REVIEW December 10, 2025 | Issue #15 | Week #14 |
![]() |
![]() |
|
Parts Unknown (DP--Disassociated Press): The 14th weekend of this year's Bookie Challenge competition was more of the same as it concerned the mundane handicapping that has become the new normal by the handicappers of the competition. With the exception of TCU, aka Too Tall Tommy, who this past weekend nailed his first 6-point parlay hit of this season and vacated 4th place of the Run-&-Shoot divisional race, and as a result, he surpassed Theopholis for third place in the division, there was only one other slight change of divisional hands and it took place within the Red Zone divisional race. More specifically, Blitzkrieg also vacated the cellar of the Red Zone division, but was only able to gain second place within the division over rookie Matty_Ice because of the league's number-one tiebreaker, of which is more best-bet wins (Blitzkrieg 12 wins vs Matty_Ice 10 wins). In the case of Blitzkrieg, despite the tiebreaker victory to gain second place over Matty_Ice, Blitzkrieg still trails the Red Zone Divisional leader 7mick7 by a substantial 10 points (the Mick 30 pts vs the Blitz 20 pts). All in all, when considering that every divisional race is being handedly led by its respective divisional leaders, as is evident by the following divisional leads in the Corozal division (the Nihilist 18-pt lead), the Run-&-Shoot division (Vikings17 10-pt lead), the Red Zone division (7mick7 10-pt lead), and in the Hail Mary division (Kr@tos 8-pt lead), the one race that is hogging all the oxygen in the contest is the race for this year's regular-season championship. That particular battle for this year's regular-season championship is mainly a three-way handicapping war of attrition among the Biased Nihilist (38 pts), Vikings17 (36 pts), and Kr@tos (35 pts). But before anyone else joins the three-way fray, they've got to start somewhere, and start right now because having time to mount a season-changing comeback is not a luxury that many handicappers have. So, in that regard, Too Tall Tommy doesn't really have the time to admire his kick-start to perhaps becoming relevant once again as a main contender for this year' overall Bookie Challenge championship. In other words, Too Tall Tommy is going to have to be a lights-out handicapper and take his handicapping skills to the next level if he wants to topple Vikings17 from the divisional lead, or for a more doable goal, he can at least try to replace Driveline for the division's wild-card slot. This past weekend, Too Tall Tommy exhibited a familiar handicapping moxie from his early years in his Challenge career and finally connected on one of his parlay combinations that consisted of only over/under selections. To begin with, TCU lost both of his best bets on this past Sunday, but his overall parlay combination ran the gamut for the three stages of the games on this past Sunday, to mean that one of his over/under selections within his parlay game was scheduled within the first slate of games on this past Sunday, and his second over/under selection was scheduled within the second slate of games, and finally, his last over/under selection was the one played on Sunday night, or the primetime game. Things got real interesting for Too Tall Tommy after he correctly predicted the first two games during the earlier slates of games played on this past Sunday. Specifically, he selected the game between Indianapolis and Jacksonville to go over the total of 48 points and the game eventually ended up with a combined 55 points being scored. For the second game of his parlay combination Too Tall Tommy had selected the game between Chicago and Green Bay to go over 45 points--and fortunately for TCU--it did (49 combined pts scored). And so with two games won on his parlay combo on this past Sunday, TCU entered Sunday night's game needing the game between Houston and Kansas City to say below 42 combined points for him to knock down his first parlay hit of this season. What a pick! The Texans' defense went on to smother the Chiefs' offense enroute to pulling off a 20-10 upset of the Chiefs, and in Kansas City no less. The 6-point parlay winner was TCU's first parlay winner since week #8 of last year's competition, of which after doing the math, it's been 25 long handicapping outings since Too Tall Tommy had connected on a 6-point parlay winner. To say the least, it was not only a much needed parlay winner but also it was a crucially needed momentum builder for the die-hard Dallas fan. Additionally, because no one else in the competition connected on a 6-point parlay winner, TCU easily was credited with the "week-won" despite him losing both of his best bets. While Too Tall Tommy's handicapping story from this past weekend made for a "feel-good story", what happened to Jets69 was so painful that trying to describe it could possibly make tears well up within every participants' eyes. In what has to be deemed as the number-one "bad beat" of this year's competition, Broadway Al, aka Jets69, endured the most excruciating defeat of a 6-point parlay hit in recent memory after the Denver Broncos botched a sure-fire pointspread cover over the Las Vegas Raiders. It was downright nasty! What follows is how the agonizing backdoor cover by the Raiders detrimentally affected Jets69's weekend, not to mention that it's possible the "bad beat" could also serve as the dagger that is plunged into Jets69's playoff hopes of pulling off a decent postseason qualification. Here's how it all went down. "Broadway Al" had chosen a parlay combination that consisted of Seattle (-7 over Atl), the LA Rams (-8 over Ari, and Denver (-7 over LV). As it turned out, Seattle clobbered Atlanta 37-9 and the LA Rams ran roughshod over Arizona 45-17. On the Raiders' ensuing possession, it took them only six plays and 1:39 off the play clock to traverse 65 yards and score a touchdown that reduced their deficit to the Broncos to 10 points (24-14). At that point in the game, and by all rights, the Broncos should have run out the clock on their next possession as there only remained 2:17 left to play in the game. However, just six plays later, after starting their drive from their own 44-yard line, the Broncos drove to the Raiders' 34 but turned the ball over on downs with just 1:56 left to play in the game. Amazingly, the Raiders drove 44 yards and in a stunning decision they kicked a 44 yard field goal with time expiring. It was a meaningless field goal, to say the least, but it was not a meaningless field goal to Jets69, who horrifically saw his fait-accompli pointspread cover bite the dust and destroy his golden opportunity to make some serious headway within the Hail Mary divisional race. Even the Biased Nihilist thought that the Broncos were a sure-fire pointspread cover that he prematurely chalked it up on his hard copy of his Picks-&-Results page as a 6-point parlay hit by Jets69, only to have to scratch over the "W" for Jets69's Denver selection and change it to an "X", which signifies a loss on the Biased Nihilist's hard copies of his weekly Pick-&-Results pages. It's a crying shame that Jets69 suffered what has to be deemed as the worst bad beat of this season, especially when considering that the failed 6-point parlay attempt could have rejuvenated his hard-luck handicapping season if only he could have come through with a parlay winner, if only fate had not been so cruel to him, not only on this past weekend but also on many previous outings this season. Case in point, after this past weekend's excruciating near-miss of a 6-point parlay winner, it marked a league-leading eighth outing this season in which Jets69 produced near-misses of his parlay combinations. As a consequence of the debilitating bad luck, Jets69 continued to stay in the dungeon of the Hail Mary divisional race and is presently a dispiriting 15 points behind the division's leader Kr@tos, who always seems to be a thorn in Broadway Al's side ever since their battle for last year's Rookie-of-the-Year honors. Moving forward, only Jets69 can pick himself up from the ground and dust himself off after this past weekend's devastating outing and stay the course, pray that his bad luck changes and that he can hit a couple of 6-point parlay winners down the stretch of this year's regular season. If anything, Jets69 can possibly pull out the Hail Mary divisional wild card over upstart rookie Kennypie86, as he presently trails the "Ken Doll" by a 7-point deficit, of which is a deficit that makes overtaking Kennypie86 very doable. |
| WEEKLY ODDS AND ENDS: THE HANDICAPPING HODGEPODGE |
|
| CHALLENGE FIELD: WEEKLY COMBINED STATS AND HAPPENINGS | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| WHO'S HOT AND WHO'S NOT |
| WHO'S HOT: TCU Choosing TCU as this week's WHO'S-HOT-HANDICAPPER was not a slam dunk decision, and it's because after this past weekend, Too Tall Tommy ended up being tied with jcvike28 for the league's worst best-bet winning percentage, of which was a disappointing .321 winning percentage (TCU 9-19-2 best-bet record vs jcvike28's 9-19-0 record). Also making the selection for this week's hottest handicapper that much harder was the fact that TCU lost both of his best-bets, and if it were not for his season-changing parlay hit from this past weekend, he would have goose egged his outing. But who else could have been selected as this week's WHO'S-HOT-HANDICAPPER of the week? Exactly, so if anything, Too Tall Tommy wins the weekly honor by default. And who knows? Maybe the 6-point outing will reinvent TCU and morph him back into being the dangerous handicapper who was highly successful in the earlier and better part of his eight-year Bookie Challenge career. What has to be remembered is how TCU had entered the Bookie Challenge back in Challenge year #7 and then proceeded to be awarded with that season's Rookie-of-the-Year honor. In his second season he belted out a phenomenal best-bet tally of 23-12-1, of which the noteworthy record resulted in an awe-inspiring .657 winning percentage for Challenge year #8. In his first two seasons, Too Tall Tommy quickly proved that he could knock down best-bet winners with the best handicappers in the league. Then, in only his third season of his Bookie Challenge career, Too Tall Tommy, also proved that he deserved the respect for being a bona fide contender to win an overall Bookie Challenge championship after he pulled a major upset in that season's Corozal divisional race and took down the Biased Nihilist to win his first-ever divisional title. It was TCU's breakout season, and although he qualified as a divisional wild card in the two ensuing seasons after his epic upset of the Biased Nihilist, the overall Bookie Challenge championship stayed just out of his reach. In the meantime, however, Too Tall Tommy continued to blast out best-bet winners despite going into a parlay-hitting slump that saw him qualify as a lowly at-large participant over the last-three seasons. Still, he entered this season with the second-highest, all-time best-bet winning percentage of .527, with only dbucc having a better all-time best-bet record. But hopefully for TCU, his first parlay hit of this season, which marked his 15th all-time 6-point parlay winner for regular-season handicapping, will change the script for TCU's handicapping season and motivate him to become one of the league's top-contenders again, just like the old days. |
| WHO'S NOT: Driveline
After this past weekend, Driveline found himself still entrenched in second place of the Run-&-Shoot divisional race but now trailing divisional leader Vikings17 by 10 points (36 pts vs 26 pts). Making matters even more frustrating for the "Fisher of Winners" (aka Driveline) is that his double-digit lead to win the division's wild-card slot over both Theopholis and TCU has been chopped down to just a 6-point lead over the now third-place TCU, who hit a 6-point parlay this past weekend to trail Driveline by just six points for the division's wild-card spot. But knowing Driveline, he's got bigger fish to fry than just besting TCU or Theopholis for the division's wild-card playoff qualification. Oh no, Driveline still has his sights focused on overtaking Vikings17 for the Run-&-Shoot divisional championship. However, overtaking Vikings17 might be a tough ask for the two-time Bookie Challenge champion. In a paradoxical twist, when looking at Driveline's stats this season, it's hard to figure out why he's not on top of his division. After all, Driveline, up until this past weekend, had held the league's top best-bet record and after this past weekend he still finished his outing with a 17-13-0 best-bet tally that comes out to a .567 winning percentage. What's more, in a Bookie Challenge season in which knocking down 6-point parlay winners is at a premium, Driveline has at least registered one of the league's 11 6-point parlay hits the field has registered this season. The Nihilist is the only handicapper who has nailed two 6-point parlay hits, so from that perspective Driveline is still in the game despite his present 10-point deficit to Vikings17. Hell, really and truly, and in retrospect, the only thing separating Driveline from the Run-&-Shoot divisional lead is the two 5-point exact-score hits that Vikings17 scrounged out in the earlier part of this season. But if the truth be told, Driveline needs to just tie Vikings17 in total points and he'll win the first tiebreaker (most best-bets won). However, with that being said, Driveline only has four weeks left to catch one of the league's surprising handicapping superstars in Vikings17. Not for nothing but Vikings17 won not only the Rookie-of-the-Year award two seasons ago but he also won that season's regular-season championship. Even more impressive was that Vikings17, aka the "Purple People Eater", won a consecutive regular-season championship in last year's competition, which was only his second Bookie Challenge competition. As a matter of record, he became the first handicapper in the history of the Bookie Challenge to win back-to-back regular-season championships, and if one can believe it, he's presently in the running to possibly win a third consecutive regular-season championship! So as can easily be seen, Driveline has his work cut out for him if he's going to usurp Vikings17 as the divisional leader of the Run-&-Shoot division. Unlike Vikings17, Driveline, who is the second-longest tenured participant of the Challenge competition (now in his 13th yr) did not have the spectacular start to his handicapping career that Vikings17 is having. In fact, in his first half of his 12 years handicapping the competition, Driveline struggled mightily with his best-bets that he dug himself a best-bet hole that he's still trying to this day to crawl out of. For example, before the start of this year's competition, Driveline ranked dead-last all-time for handicapping best bets among all the handicappers, active or non-active, who qualify for all-time records. He started this season with a lifetime best-bet record of 264-304-17, which factors out to an all-time league-low .456 winning percentage. The question has to be asked about Driveline: "does he have the strong-mindedness to mount a comeback and dethrone Vikings17?" After all, he's done it before, meaning that he and the Nihilist--in the same season and in the same divisional race--made the largest divisional comebacks in the history of the competition's divisional races. However, something is a little off with Driveline's handicapping, as in Driveline has yet to catch fire and exude that handicapping steadfastness that has made him one of the toughest handicappers in the league. As an example, this past weekend, Driveline plopped down his second consecutive GOLDEN GOOSE EGG. Almost every participant in the league might not know how extremely difficult it is to lay consecutive golden goose eggs, so here it is...laying back-to-back golden goose eggs has only happened ONCE in the 13-year history of the Bookie Challenge competition, of which the shameful feat was only registered by LTFrankDrebben back in Challenge year #5. |
| POINT STANDINGS (Thru Week #14) | |||||||||||||||
| COROZAL DIVISION | |||||||||||||||
| Total Pts | Participant | Best Bet Record | Win % | Weeks Won | Exact Scores 5pt--------2pt- -------1pt |
Propositional Pts | 3pt Parlays | 6pt Parlays | Perfectas | Goose Eggs | Golden Goose-Eggs | Wins in Parlays | |||
| 38 pts | B.Nihilist* | 17-12-1 | .586 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 1pt(x3) | 9 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 20 | |
| 20 pts | jcvike28* | 9-19-0 | .321 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1pt(x4) | 11 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 5 | 1 | 16 | |
| HAIL MARY DIVISION | |||||||||||||||
| Total Pts | Participant | Best Bet Record | Win % | Weeks Won | Exact Scores 5pt--------2pt- -------1pt |
Propositional Pts | 3pt Parlays | 6pt Parlays | Perfectas | Goose Eggs | Golden Goose-Eggs | Wins in Parlays | |||
| 35 pts | Kr@tos* | 16-13-1 | .552 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1pt(x3) | 10 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 3 | 14 | |
| 27 pts | Kennypie86* | 13-12-0 | .478 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 1pt(x4) | 8 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 4 | 0 | 12 | |
| 25 pts | dbucc* | 9-15-0 | .375 | 1 | 5pt(x1) | 0 | 1pt(x5) | 10 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 4 | 0 | 18 | |
| 20 pts | Jets69* | 18-12-0 | .600 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1pt(x2) | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 21 | |
| RUN-&-SHOOT DIVISION | |||||||||||||||
| Total Pts | Participant | Best Bet Record | Win % | Weeks Won | Exact Scores 5pt--------2pt- -------1pt |
Propositional Pts | 3pt Parlays | 6pt Parlays | Perfectas | Goose Eggs | Golden Goose-Eggs | Wins in Parlays | |||
| 36 pts | Vikings17* | 13-17-0 | .433 | 1 | 5pt(x2) | 0 | 1pt(x3) | 17 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 21 | |
| 26 pts | Driveline* | 17-13-0 | .567 | 0 | 0 | 2pt(x1) | 1pt(x1) | 3 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 20 | |
| 20 pts | TCU* | 9-19-2 | .321 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1pt(x2) | 5 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 4 | 0 | 17 | |
| 17 pts | Theopholis* | 13-11-0 | .542 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1pt(x4) | 4 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 11 | |
| RED ZONE DIVISION | |||||||||||||||
| Total Pts | Participant | Best Bet Record | Win % | Weeks Won | Exact Scores 5pt--------2pt- -------1pt |
Propositional Pts | 3pt Parlays | 6pt Parlays | Perfectas | Goose Eggs | Golden Goose-Eggs | Wins in Parlays | |||
| 30 pts | 7mick7* | 11-18-0 | .379 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 1pt(x3) | 13 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 3 | 1 | 18 | |
| 20 pts | Blitzkrieg* | 12-16-2 | .429 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1pt(x2) | 2 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 5 | 0 | 21 | |
| 20 pts | Matty_Ice* | 10-16-2 | .385 | 0 | 0 | 2pt(x1) | 1pt(x1) | 10 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 5 | 0 | 17 | |
| PLEASE NOTE: The Hall-of-Fame City Kid (Corozal division) and DawgPound (Red Zone division) have been dropped from the Pt. Standings for non-participation and for not submitting membership fees. | |||||||||||||||
| Statistics in BOLD denotes participant leads league in statistical category. | |||||||||||||||
| Asterisk next to participant's name denotes his membership fees have been received. Total projected jackpot: $750 (Current jackpot: $500). Projected split of jackpot: 1st place at end of playoffs $500, 2nd place at end of playoffs $100, 3rd place prize Regular season champion $100, and 4th place prize overall Top Seed from divisional seeding (Wk#8) $50. | |||||||||||||||
| INDIVIDUAL PICKS (NFL WEEK #14) (Note: Participants are listed in order in which they posted their picks) |
||||||||||||||||||
| Participant | Best Bets | Parlay | Exact Scores | Propositional Picks | Results >>>>> | Total Pts | W-L-T | Week Won | Exact-Scores 5pt------2pt------1pt |
Propositional Pts | 3pt parlay | 6pt parlay | Perfecta | Goose Egg | Golden Goose-Egg | Wins in Parlay | ||
| Kennypie86 | Mia-2½-W Sea-7-W |
TB-9-L Chi+7-L Phi/LAC-O41-L |
Dall 34-20 LAC 34-17 |
N/A | >>>>> | 2 pts | 2-0-0 | 0/3 | ||||||||||
| Jets69 | Jax+1½-W Buff-5½-L |
LAR-8-W Den-7-L Sea-7-W |
Dall 31-21 Phi 24-17 |
N/A | >>>>> | 1 pts | 1-1-0 | 2/3 | ||||||||||
| Blitzkrieg | Mia-2½-W Den-7½-L |
Phil-3-L Cle-4-L Jax+2-W |
Dall 27-24 Phi 27-20 |
N/A | >>>>> | 1 pts | 1-1-0 | 1/3 | ||||||||||
| dbucc | Dall+3-L Sea-7-W |
Chi+7-L TB-9-L Den-7-L |
Dall 30-24-W Phi 27-17 |
N/A | >>>>> | 2 pts | 1-1-0 | 1pt | PP-1pt | 0/3 | ||||||||
| TCU | Cle-4-L Den-7½-L |
Chi/GB-O45-W Hou/KC-U42-W Ind/Jax-O48-W |
Dall 32-31 LAC 24-20 |
N/A | >>>>> | 6 pts | 0-2-0 | WW | 6pt | W-3/3 | ||||||||
| 7mick7 | Mia-2½-W Cle-4-L |
TB-9-L Hou/KC-O42-L Was/Min-O42-L |
Det 27-24 Phi 24-20 |
N/A | >>>>> | 1 pts | 1-1-0 | 0/3 | ||||||||||
| Vikings17 | LAR-8-W LAR/Ari-O47½-W |
Was/Min-O42-L Mia/NYJ-O42-W Phi/LAC-O41-L |
Dall 30-27-W Phil 23-20 |
N/A | >>>>> | 3 pts | 2-0-0 | 1pt | PP-1pt | 1/3 | ||||||||
| Kr@tos | Mia-2½-W LAC+3-W |
TB-9-L Buff-6-L Phi/LAC-O41-L |
Dall 34-31 LAC 27-24 |
N/A | >>>>> | 2 pts | 2-0-0 | 0/3 | Driveline | Balt-6-L Buff-5½-L |
Chi+7-L KC-3-L Phil-3-L |
Dall 24-20 Phi 27-17 |
N/A | >>>>> | 0 pts | 0-2-0 | GGE | 0/3 |
| B.Nihilist | Balt-6-L Jax+1½-W |
Cin/Buf-U54-L Den-7-L LAR-8-W |
Det 31-28 Phi 24-20 |
N/A | >>>>> | 1 pts | 1-1-0 | 1/3 | ||||||||||
| jcvike28 | Mia-2½-W Chi/GB-U44½-L |
Jax+2-W Cin+6-W Phil-3-L |
NoPick Phi 24-17 |
N/A | >>>>> | 1 pts | 1-1-0 | 2/3 | ||||||||||
| Matty_Ice | Chi+6½-L KC-3½-L |
Cin/Buf-O54-W Ind/Jax-U48-L NO/TB-U43-L |
NoPick Phi 32-29 |
N/A | >>>>> | 0 pts | 0-2-0 | GE | 1/3 | |||||||||
| Theopholis | Minn-2-W Cle-4-L |
Buff-6-L Atl+7-L LAR-8-W |
NoPick LAC 21-19--W |
N/A | >>>>> | 2 pts | 1-1-0 | 1pt | PP-1pt | 1/3 | ||||||||
| FINALS | DET 44 DALL 30 |
MINN 31 WASH 0 |
MIA 34 NYJ 10 |
TENN 31 CLE 29 |
PITTS 27 BALT 22 |
SEA 37 ATL 9 |
JAX36 IND 19 |
NO 24 TB 20 |
BUFF 39 CIN 34 |
DEN 24 LV 17 |
GB 28 CHI 21 |
LAR 45 ARI 17 |
HOU 20 KC 10 |
LAC 22 PHIL 19 |
| PREVIOUS REVIEWS | Annual Special | Wk#1 | Wk#2 | Wk#3 | Wk#4 | Wk#5 | Wk#6 | Wk#7 | Wk#8 | Wk#9 | Wk#10 | Wk#11 | Wk#12 | Wk#13Thx |