Home Message Board Pick 'em Page Picks & Results Pt Standings Wkly Composites Official Rules Awards Record Archives Handicapper Capsules
Bookie Challenge
WEEKLY REVIEW

September 14, 2023 | Issue #2 | Week #1

Parts Unknown (DP--Disassociated Press):

The 13th Annual Bookie Challenge competition got underway this past weekend with a bang, of sorts, after three handicappers--DawgPound, catman23, and DIRTYBIRDS--each landed 6-point parlay winners in this year's regular-season opener. As a result, all three handicappers rose quickly to the top of the Challenge point standings and established early leads in this year's competition. However, because DIRTYBIRDS misfired on both of his best bets this past weekend, and because both DawgPound and catman23 each split their respective best bets, the Birdman finished the opener with six points and just one point behind the two front-runners DawgPound and catman for the overall lead in the point standings. As it concerned the rest of the Challenge field this past weekend, other than both TCU and Blitzkrieg connecting on both of their respective best bets, the majority of the handicappers had break-even outings with the exceptions of this year's two rookie entrants Vikings17 and Hall of Fame City kid, both of whom goose egged their rookie debuts. The weekend's overall scoring could have been much more explosive, but seven handicappers just missed connecting on 6-point parlay winners because of only one loser within their respective parlay combinations. Of course, although only one week of this year's competition is already in the books, this year's opener kicked off the all-important rat race to see who will win one of the top-four seeds at this year's week #8 divisional seeding. Not for nothing, but winning one of the top-four seeds at a divisional seeding, especially the #1 overall seed, is a big deal that ends the first significant phase of Bookie Challenge competition.

After registering respective 7-point outings this past weekend, both DawgPound and catman23 are the two handicappers who are presently in the driver's seats. In the case of DawgPound, he connected on his 9th all-time 6-point parlay winner, and the parlay hit this past weekend marked the second time in DawgPound's 5-year Challenge career that he has opened up a competition with 6-point parlay hit. Incredibly, DawgPound's other opening-day parlay hit came in his rookie season (Challenge Yr #8), when he knocked down a PERFECTA outing on his first week of handicapping the Bookie Challenge competition. In fact, in that same season, another rookie, H.E. PennyPacker, also recorded a PERFECTA outing in his Challenge debut, thus making him and DawgPound as the only two rookies in the history of the competition to hit PERFECTA outings to start off their respective Challenge careers. Don't look now, but DawgPound is starting to shape up as one of the league's top contenders for a Bookie Challenge championship. His impressive start to this season has come in the heels of a stupedous performance in last year's competition, when he went on to win the second-place prize of the Latinum jackpot in last year's postseason.

The propitious start to this season by catman23 is a whole different story, especially when considering his rocky first-four years handicapping the competition. For starters, he quit his initial three handicapping campaigns before the end of each of its regular seasons, and it wasn't until last year's competition that he logged in a full year of participating in a regular season. With that in mind, it should be needless to say that the jury is still out on catman when it concerns his total commitment to earnestly compete in a full Challenge competition. However, if anything can jump start him to take the competition more seriously and get his heart on becoming a significant competitor, it's this past weekend's hot start to the season. This past weekend's parlay winner was just catman's third overall 6-point parlay hit of his 5-year Challenge career, which includes this season. But if the "Tomcat from Handicapping Alley" wants to truly exorcise his ignominious reputation from his first-three seasons and become a reputable handicapper in the competition, he'll need to hit more parlay winners this season to shed his losing ways from the past and turn things around, prove that he can become a noteworthy and compelling handicapper in the competition. Of course, only time will tell if he will finally pour his heart and soul into the competition and get himself on the Bookie Challenge map.

Like catman23, DIRTYBIRDS also needed a 6-point parlay winner in a worst way, if anything, to at least boost his confidence once again within his up-and-down Challenge career, with this season being his 5th overall. But unlike catman, DIRTYBIRDS' good start to this competition isn't the first time he's gotten off to a commendable beginning to a Bookie Challenge competition. Two years ago, Challenge year #11, he shocked the Bookie Challenge world by seizing that season's #1 overall top seed at that year's divisional season. Unfortunately, the competition's youngest member failed to win a divisional title despite his advantageous seeding, and subsequently became the first #1 top seed from a divisional seeding to not win a divisional championship. This past weekend, the Birdman registered his 5th all-time 6-point parlay winner, and in the process he snapped a parlay drought that lasted all of last season and the last 4 weeks of the previous season, which adds up to a total of 23 consecutive weeks in which he failed to connect on a parlay winner. To note, of the overall 6-point parlay winners in his career, this past weekend marked the first time DIRTYBIRDS failed to connect on both of his best bets to complement a parlay hit. Regardless, the huge parlay winner this past weekend has the Birdman in a good place again, just one point off the overall lead in the point standings. One thing is for certain, especially after his parlay winner to start off the season, DIRTYBIRDS is champing at the bit to continue his splendid start to this season and perhaps win a second #1 overall top seed at this year's divisional seeding.


WEEKLY ODDS AND ENDS: THE HANDICAPPING HODGEPODGE

  • THEOPHOLIS AT IT AGAIN: Leave it to the Bookie Challenge's most eccentric handicapper to flop another set of weekly picks. Without question, Theo has failed to submit more weekly sets of picks than any other participant in the history of the Bookie Challenge, and it's not even close. Oh, and of the weekly set of picks that Theopolis has managed to submit over the span of his 9-year Challenge career, he has also had more picks disqualified than any other handicapper in the history of the competition--bar none! What defies logical is that he's doing it again! This past Thursday night, Theo submitted one of his best bets for the week, Detroit +5½ versus Kansas City, of which he won. Then came Sunday, and what does Theo do? He got the bright idea to introduce a best-bet parlay combo to the competition, as in he posted two more best bets on this past Sunday, taking Chicago over Green Bay and Minnesota over Tampa Bay, instead of just posting one remaining best bet for the week. And that's not the half of it! Theopholis did not submit his Super Bowl selections--um--for the third time in his Challenge career! Back in Challenge year #10, just like he did this season, Theo also forgot to submit his Super Bowl selections. But in Challenge year #7, in week #1 of that season, Theopholis did manage to post his Super Bowl selections, but did so 10 hours after that Sunday's posting deadline.

  • WEEKLY TICKER ......For the first time in the history of the Bookie Challenge, in this past weekend's point standings, no participant led the league in any statistical category.....TONY SOPRANO GETS WHACKED: One of the best handicappers in the history of the competition has called it quits after handicapping 11 overall competitions.....TCU'S NEW OVER/UNDER COMPETITION?: TCU by far posts more over/under selections than any other handicapper in the league. But rookie entrant Vikings17 might be the next over/under heavyweight after posting two over/under selections within his parlay combo this past weekend to start his Challenge career.....New changes to exact-score picks met its intended aim for Thursday night games after 10 overall participants submitted picks. The 10 exact-score picks were the highest amount ever submitted for a Thursday night game....


CHALLENGE FIELD: WEEKLY COMBINED STATS AND HAPPENINGS
WEEKLY RESULTS (Thru Week #1)
Week/YTD Best Bet Record Win % Total Pts Exact-Scores

5pt-------2pt---------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt Parlays 6pt Parlays Perfectas Goose Eggs Golden Goose Eggs Wins Within Parlay Consensus Picks
Week #1 13-14-0 .481 36 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 2 0 27 consensus 1-0-0
W% 1.000
YTD 13-14-0 .481 36 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 2 0 27 consensus 1-0-0
W% 1.000
Single-Season
Records
504-414-33
(Yr#5)
.549 (Yr#5) 1087 (Yr#8) 4
(Yrs #8
& #6)
N/A 3
(Yr#12)
181
(Yr#8)
9
(Yr#7)
56 (Yr#8) 19
(Yr#8)
92 (Yr#8) 23 (Yr#4) 631 (Yr#8) 16-8-2
W%.667 (Yr#4)

  • CHALLENGE FIELD OPENS SEASON WITH THREE 6-POINT PARLAY HITS, BUT FALLS SHORT OF TYING ALL-TIME RECORD: The Bookie Challenge field as a whole got off to a halfway decent start to the 13th annual competition. Primarily, the field churned out three 6-point parlay hits, which is the third time it had opened up a competition with the same amount of parlay hits. However, the field fell short by just one more parlay winner from tying the all-time record of four opening-day parlay hits, of which the all-time mark was established by the Challenge field from Challenge year #5. Moreover, apart from the mini parlay outburst, the field finished the weekend with a nearly .500 best-bet record (13-14-0/Win% .481), won its consensus pick (Jax -5 over Indy), won an overall and not-to-shabby 27 parlay wins within its combined parlay selections, and only laid two goose eggs. All in all, the field did okay, not spectacular, but by no means horrible either.


WHO'S HOT AND WHO'S NOT
WHO'S HOT: DawgPound

As already mentioned in this weekly review, it appears that DawgPound is morphing into one of the league's better handicappers right before our very eyes. Before anyone forgets, in his rookie year (Challenge year #8), the "Dawg-Day-Afternoon Handicapper" pounded out that season's top best-bet record and was automatically bestowed with that season's Swami award. For sure, he had an otherworldy start in Challenge year #8 to begin his Challenge career. Interestingly, after his outstanding rookie season, the Dawg developed a unique handicapping pattern that saw him alternate good seasons and bad seasons, of which this season the uncanny pattern called for a bad handicapping campaign. However, after his hot start to this year's competition, DawgPound is seemingly dispersing with the have-one-good-season-bomb-the-next oddity. What's gone under the radar during DawgPound's present handicapping transformation is that he's on a consecutive scoring streak ever since the second weekend of last year's competition, as in he scored at least one point in the remaining 22 weekends of last year's contest to set a new all-time record for consecutive scoring, of which his streak broke the previous mark of 18 weeks in a row that was previously co-shared by Tony Soprano and Bomber7. The kicker of it all? DawgPound is still extending his all-time consecutive scoring streak, and after scoring seven points this past weekend--his scoring streak is now at 23 weeks in a row. There's also one last handicapping tidbit that DawgPound miraculously pulled off last season. He became the first handicapper to exactly predict the propositional selection for the longest TD of a game, meaning he not only had the right team selected for the longest TD but also predicted the exact yardage of the scoring play, of which the incredible prop pick totaled out to eight overall points for the perfect selection (3 pts for hitting the prop pick and 5 bonus pts for getting the exact yardage right). So yeah, DawgPound opens the 13th annual competition as the HOTTEST HANDICAPPER in the league, and deservingly so.

WHO'S NOT: Rookies Hall of Fame City Kid and Vikings17

So you wanna be a Bookie Challenge handicapper, huh? Well, we've got some bad news greenhorns, picking winners in the Bookie Challenge isn't as easy as plucking low-hanging apples from a crab-apple tree. For the record, in the history of the Bookie Challenge, only four rookies have had scoreless outings to kick off their respective Bookie Challenge debuts, and those sorry-ass openers all occured in seperate seasons: 7mick7-GE-Yr#2; dbucc-GGE-Yr#4; TCU-GGE-Yr#7; and yankeefan7-GE-Yr#11. But never in the history of the competition have two rookie entrants both goose egg their respective rookie debuts in the same season, that is, until this past weekend. But hey, at least HOF City Kid won two parlay picks within his 3-team parlay combo, whereas Vikings17 only won one of his three parlay sections and almost laid a golden goose egg (when participant losses all 5 picks submitted for the weekend). Granted, it was the first-ever weekend both rookies handicapped a Bookie Challenge competition, so each deserves a mulligan, but being greenhorns doesn't mean they can't produce breathtaking debuts. Case in point? In Challenge year #8, both DawgPound and H.E. PennyPacker opened up their respective rookie debuts with PERFECTA outings. If the two rookies this season don't see where this is going, they had better take off their blind-man glasses and see where the hell they're headed. THIS IS THE BOOKIE CHALLENGE COMPETITION! And the primary goal of the competition is to score points, a lot of points if a handicapper wants a legit chance to win an overall Bookie Challenge championship.


POINT STANDINGS (Thru Week #1)
Total Pts Participant Best Bet Record Win % Weeks Won
Exact Scores

5pt--------2pt- -------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt Parlays 6pt Parlays Perfectas Goose Eggs Golden Goose-Eggs Wins in Parlays
7 Pts catman23* 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 3
7 Pts DawgPound 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 3
6 Pts DIRTYBIRDS 0-2-0 .000 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 3
2 Pts TCU* 2-0-0 1.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
2 Pts Blitzkrieg 2-0-0 1.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1 Pts Theopholis 1-0-0 1.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
1 Pts B.Nihilist* 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
1 Pts dbucc* 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
1 Pts 7mick7* 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
1 Pts Driveline* 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
1 Pts jcvike28* 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
1 Pts moemonie* 1-1-0 .500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 Pts  HOF City Kid* 0-2-0 .000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2
0 Pts Vikings17* 0-2-0 .000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1
Statistics in BOLD denotes participant leads league in statistical category.
*Asterisk next to participant's name denotes participant's Latinum has been received. Total projected jackpot: $560 (Current jackpot: $400). Projected split of jackpot: 1st place $420 (BC Champion); 2nd place $100 (Runner up to BC Champion), 3rd place $40 (Regular Season Champion)

INDIVIDUAL PICKS (Week #1)
(Note: Participants are listed in order in which they posted their picks)
Participant Best Bets Parlay Exact Scores Propositional Picks Results >>>>> Total Pts W-L-T Week Won Exact-Scores

5pt------2pt------1pt
Propositional Pts 3pt parlay 6pt parlay Perfecta Goose Egg Golden Goose-Egg Wins in Parlay
B.Nihilist LV+3½-W
Buff-2½-L
Jax-5-W
Tenn+3-W
LAC-3-L
KC 27-24

Buff 27-20
SB: Buff over Dall >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
DawgPound Det+5½-W
Wash-7-L
Cle+3-W
Jax-5-W
Dall-3-W
KC 24-23

Buff 27-24
SB: Cle over Phi >>>>> 7 pts 1-1-0 6pt W-3/3
Theopholis Det+5½-W

Chi & Minn?-DQ
Hou+10-L
Cle+3-W
Car/Atl-O40-L
KC 32-28

Buff 23-21
No SB picks submitted >>>>> 1 pts 1-0-0 1/3
Blitzkrieg Atl-3½-W
Jax-5-W
Sea-6-L
LAC-3-L
Wash-7-L
KC 24-20

Buff 27-24
SB: KC over SF >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 0/3
Vikings17 Chi-1-L
NYG+3½-L
Mia/LAC-O51-W
Buf/NYJ-O47-L
Wash-7-L
KC 31-27

NYJ 30-24
SB: Cin over SF >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GE 1/2
catman23 Cle+2½-W
Chi-1-L
SF-3-W
Dall-3-W
Phil-4-W
KC 24-7

Buff 24-17
SB: SF over Cin >>>>> 7 pts 1-1-0 6pt W-3/3
dbucc Det+5½-W
Sea-5½-L
Jax-5-W
Wash-7-L
Phil-4-W
Det 27-24

Buff 24-20
SB: Phi over Cin >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
7mick7 Jax-5-W
Wash-7-L
Phil-4-W
LV/Den-U44-W
Minn-6-L
KC 27-10

Buff 24-20
SB: KC over SF >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
HOF City Kid NO-3-L
Minn-6-L
Cle+3-W
SF-3-W
Wash-7-L
KC 23-20

Buff 20-17
SB: SF over Blt >>>>> 0 pts 0-2-0 GE 2/3
moemonie Det+5½-W
Ind+5-L
Cle+3-W
Pitts+3-L
NE+4-L
KC 31-27

Buff 24-20
SB: Phi over Cin >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 1/3
DIRTYBIRDS Hou+10-L
Cin-2½-L
Atl-3-W
Phil-4-W
Jax-5-W
xs

Buff 21-17
SB: Buff over Dall >>>>> 6 pts 0-2-0 6pt W-3/3
Driveline SF-2½-W
Sea-5½-L
Phil-4-W
Tenn+3-W
NYG+3-L
xs

Buff 31-17
SB: Phi over Buff >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3
TCU Phil-4-W
Balt-10-W
Ari/Was-U39-W
Jax-5-W
Cin/Cle-O48-L
xs

NYJ 31-28
SB: Dall over Buff >>>>> 2 pts 2-0-0 2/3
jcvike28 SF-2½-W
Sea-5½-L
Atl-3-W
Jax-5-W
Den-3-L
xs

Buff 24-20
SB:Buff over SF >>>>> 1 pts 1-1-0 2/3

FINALS DET 21
KC 20
ATL 24
CAR 10
BALT 25
HOU 9
CLE 24
CIN 3
JAX 31
IND 21
TB 20
MIN 17
N0 16
NO 15
SF 30
PITTS 7
WASH 20
ARI 16
GB 38
CHI 20
LV 17
DEN 16
MIA 36
LAC 34
PHIL 25
NE 20
LAR 30
SEA 13
DALL 40
NYG 0
NYJ 22
BUFF 16

PREVIOUS REVIEWS Preseason Special WK #1